Gatsby's — Restaurant in Mifflin Township

Very cool place. Old school small town bar. Biker friendly. I hung out with the tight knit regulars. I felt very welcomed. The bartender and owner let me stay and finish watching my hockey game. I never felt rushed.

The food is out of this world delicious. Prepared fresh. They sourced fresh ingredients. The pickle was great. They pay attention to the small things in food preparation.

The bathrooms are very clean and well maintained. Spotless toilets, urinals, sinks, floors, fixtures, ect. No foul odors. We'll stocked toilet paper, and soap. I used 2 men's rooms. I'm a man, and only saw the 2 men's room. Also I noticed.... no graffiti in the bathroom. Nothing even scratches in the stall doors.

This place is old school, and has that local hangout vibe. But the are welcoming of everyone. Come here for a fun time, friendly staff,, good food, and immaculate...

I've been to Gatsby's a few times. I love small hometown businesses. I just left about 20 minutes ago and was really disappointed. I ordered my drink, salad and main entree. Around 20 minutes after the order was placed, we received our check. I asked when my main entree, a fish sandwich, would arrive, to which the waitress replied "You did not order a fish sandwich. I know what you ordered, the Cobb salad. You didn't order a fish sandwich". I was taken aback. Ok, so maybe I didn't order it, which I know I did, but the issue was handled unprofessionally. I own a local small business. Customer service pays the bills. I'm leaving with a salty taste in my mouth and probably won't be back. The correct way to handle it would have been to apologize and put the order in. Not blame the customer. I know it may seem petty, but this waitress is your first...

Went here with some ladies for the first time tonight for dinner and bingo. The place was completely full upstairs. The owner Doug actually brought up a folding table and put the six of us in the middle of the room and let us eat and play there. How amazing is he!! Our waitress Kim was fantastic as well! She was so busy with all the people, but working hard. Both Kim and Doug kept talking to us and hanging out like they were our friends. Bingo was a blast and plays for big money by the end of the game. Doug also kept coming around and seeing if we needed to buy more tickets or check cards. Downstairs they were playing darts and seemed to be having fun too. The food was pretty good. Chicken sandwich was really bland but the onion rings were great! Con is really how small the place is, so it's really packed. It was a good time with...