Papa's Pizza — Restaurant in Milford

I've been a return customer for about 10 years. Unfortunately, my experience today convinced me not to return. This is a top dollar location. Today I paid the most money I've ever spent here, received the least amount of food ever and it was poorly assembled to boot. Gone are the days of a pizza that just.barely fits into the box. My large pizza was small, oddly shaped and oddly cut. The two meatball cones I ordered were served in old bread and with half the number of meatballs I've come to expect. Didn't bother calling to complain because it's over an hour round trip. I hope this is just a one off, but I won't ever come back...

I personally think it's the best in milford I think gigi's is a very close second. But papas is new haven style pizza really really good we've been getting it once a week for years only thing is wish they delivered. But it's so worth the 2 min drive it's the cheese the sauce and the dough that really make. We def give it 5 stars for number 1 in milford. They also make great salads and meals but for the meals we go to gigi's its outstanding Italian food. Very traditional food excellent tasting food. We love going there as...

By far the BEST pizza in town! I live across town (near West Haven) and get my pizza here every single time! All their specialty pies are OFF THE CHARTS amazing - love the sauce on the pies!!! Stacy who works typically on Fridays, is by far the nicest, friendliest, and best server at the window!!! They are all great people but she makes the visit even more special as she engages with each and every customer that comes by to pick up their orders! LOVE LOVE LOVE Papa's Pizza on...