Pizza Man's Pizza — Restaurant in New Castle

Always great food and Sandy is always cheerful and great smile. I have lower back problems and the seats are so soft I sink in and can't straighten my back its hard to sit. So I usually have things delivered either way it's the taste or the dough and sauce but the sandwiches are really good the size of the wings is Alot larger then other pizza shops Pauly and his family are great Mike is my brother in law and his family were over a lot everyone of them would make me laugh because of their great personalities they seemed always up beat.I love the calzones and I like to get them filled with as much toppings as I can afford at that moment although the prices have always been great. A lady in my building love the buns and sliced of bread they add to certian menu items she saus she's love fried peppers and egg sandwiches with the bread. You guys do a great job my mom and dad love it also thanks for treating...

I traveled over to Newcastle from Ohio to pick up a car part and stopped because we were hungry and found this restaurant. I must say the pizza is excellent. I came back to Ohio to get a slice of New York style pizza from Ohio a pizzeria that I go to all the time and now I hate it because I came to Pizza Man pizza and tasted their New York style pizza And it’s a huge difference. I will definitely return. I think I’m gonna drive up soon. I told my friends we were gonna do a small road trip just to get pizza they’re chicken wings are great as well. I’ve tried strawberry hot wings never had that before, but it was great , the atmosphere was nice. The people were respectful there was a little bit of a weight on the food but overall the food taste in ingredients and freshness trumps anything definitely a must stop and try. I’ll be...

I have had mixed experiences with this place. half of the time the crust is undercooked and doughy. I don't know if theyre trying to save money by skimping on cheese or if they want to be like Augustine's pizza but there is usually only cheese on half of it, like two inches of cheese and just two inches of sauce and then the crust. The taste of the pizza is good but the overall haste in preparing it and everything else lacking on it makes it not so great. they use tiny pieces of pepperoni about the size of a nickel and only put a few of them on. I used to buy pizza there every Wednesday on their "wacko Wednesday" deal but not anymore. I'd rather pay full price for a pizza across the street at town mall pizza and get what I pay for with...