Theo's Downtown Diner — Restaurant in New Milford

Typically a nice place to go for an occasional breakfast, however our recent expirence here left a bad taste in our mouth. The waitress was flat-out rude and seemed to target our table with her frustrations. She wouldn't let me order a coffee for my husband, who was parking the car, and then when taking away the menus, she hit him in the face with it and didn't apologize. Her overall demenor with us throughout our meal was short and not welcoming. When asking how to split the check, our group took a moment to think how we wanted to pay and instead of allowing us to answer said in not so friendly tone "I don't want you getting up to the register and then make me split it." Having a bad day is completely understandable, but please leave those feelings at the door when dealing with regular customers who spend money at your establishment. Outside of this experience, the food is decent, and service is...

What a great place!! My wife and I lucked upon this place after reading prior Yelp reviews. Our first time there, but certainly won't be our last!! Just be aware, they are only open for breakfast and lunch.

The servers are friendly, polite, welcoming, and accommodating. The atmosphere is casual, yet trendy, yet comfortable :) Very clean, and well maintained. Cozy, modern feel.

The food rocks!! I had an omelette with ham, fresh spinach, and feta cheese.. it was delicious, and huge!!! The home fries were the best I've ever had!! My wife had a turkey reuben, and she couldn't stop raving. Also huge!! The special side of the day was potato salad, and it was one of the most flavorable potato salads we've ever had.

As I said before, first visit, won't...

I called to pick up my order for 3 people. I walk in and there's 2 women at the register. The order ticket is stapled to the bag, so why is it necessary to emphasize that "only THIS BAG is yours, NOT BOTH"? Adding insult, she wasn't even the cashier 🙄 I'm complaining because this isn't the first cold reception I've gotten when I've gone to Theo's.

My girlfriend ordered Eggs Benedict with a "side of hollandaise". The eggs were firm and a side of hollandaise was poured on top of the food. A side of something denotes separate from the order. Not too hard to grasp the meaning of that.

I love Theo's food though. Their home fries are seasoned perfectly. The taste of their sausage is yummy. From what I'm hearing, their hollandaise is...