Bartolino's - Fine Italian Cuisine — Restaurant in New York

Do not judge a book by its cover! The place is small and unsuspecting - it used to be a low key neighborhood bar frequented by locals - but the food is UNFORGETTABLE! We had the spaghetti bolognese, chicken piccata (with side of pasta) and the vanilla and chocolate cannolis. The food was fresh, flavorful, and filling! Portion sizes are not gigantic, they are “Goldie locks” sized. The spaghetti bolognese was hands down the best I’ve ever had! The menu is very straightforward - they don’t overwhelm you with “novelty” dishes, they’re not trying to lure you in with gimmicky dishes - they have the classics, so you really can’t go wrong!

Our waitress was very friendly and attentive, and the manager and owner were very warm and welcoming. Ambience is very low key, no fuss no frills - (we showed up in sweats lol)

HIGHLY RECOMMEND if you’re looking for a fantastic, filling, and casual meal, this is the spot!! Happy they added this place to the...

I have been to this place for Friends reunion and had an awesome time, My husband won in a raffle gift certificates for this restaurant we went in tonight to eat dinner, I had the shrimp cocktail for an appetizer they was so big and delicious, my husband had the muscles and he enjoyed them very much, usually when I go to an Italian restaurant I always order chicken francese but this place can top that!! They add mozzarella cheese and fresh tomatoes... it was so delicious! ,My husband had the seafood Fra Diavolo the plates were unbelievable there was so much food we had to bring some home, The manager Dominic was such a sweetheart if you need a good wine for your dinner ask him, and our waiter Benny was a real sweetheart he was on top of everything. This place...

Such an amazing Italian restaurant. We walked in our party of four with no reservation and the maître d’ greeted us and quickly walked us to our table. Everyone greeted us and thanked us for Dining with them last night. The bread was warm the butter was sweet. The drinks were perfection. My wife Stated she never had a nice tea that was so delicious.We had the shrimp Parmesan and I had the gnocchi with bolognese sauce which melted in my mouth. Such a pillow of happiness. And to top it off the end of the night we all had complementary lemon-cello. This was my first time going there but this will not be the last time. We left with our bellies fully and Smiles on all of our faces. Such a hidden gem I will...