Bay Ridge Pizza — Restaurant in New York

Nothing compares to Bay Ridge Pizza! And I am speaking from experience! A few years ago, my family and I moved out of Brooklyn (a big mistake) thinking that we could find happiness in Staten Island. Well, Staten Island is beautiful, it's quiet, and the people are decent. It reminds me of how Bay Ridge used to be. However, even though many pizza owners left Brooklyn and moved to Staten Island, their pizza stinks! And I have lived on the island for over five years and I have yet to find a great pizzeria! Every now and then I go to Brooklyn for business, and this time I decided to stop by Bay Ridge Pizza, and it's interesting because I now don a beard, and through the beard and all, my old friend Gasper, the owner of the establishment, recognized me! He said, "Hey! I haven't seen you in such a long time, but it felt like yesterday since I last saw him. " I told him, "I miss your pizza because it is the absolute best pizza in Brooklyn, NY!" It is actually second to none, and I have tried pizza from several pizzerias. Gasper, his workers, and the cooks are all great people. Gasper even prepares the pizza before baking! Not many owners do that nowadays!

Having said that, you should try their pizza. You won't be disappointed, and their entrees are excellent too! It is true Italian pizza the way we had it back in the...

Honestly, one of the grossest things I’ve eaten in the neighborhood. I had two “OK” experiences with this place, so today, I decided to try ordering online for delivery.

Their online menu is incomplete, and I mistook the pie I wanted for something else. I took ownership of that and prayed it wasn’t terrible. It was.

The business called me to confirm the size of the pie, so it got off to a bad start. When I realized she said “Buffalo chicken,” I immediately called her back and said, “listen, I think I put the wrong thing through because the menu appears incomplete. I want a chicken, bacon, ranch.”

She puts me on-hold, angry arguing in the background, and she comes back on the line to tell me it would be an additional fee to change the order they hadn’t even started. I let her know it was the same price and I wasn’t paying a fee.

Well, I got it, and the chicken tasted awful, the pie was doughy, and I threw it in the trash and wrote it off to a bad time. This probably could have been avoided if they just switched my order over to the thing I’d had before and trusted, but here we are. I definitely...

As a guy who LOVES pizza, I’ve gotta say definitely not the “best pizza in bay ridge” way too overpriced, I payed $20 for one slice buffalo chicken one order of cheese sticks and a chicken spinach sandwich. It would’ve been fine but the food wasn’t all too good either , cheese sticks soggy and chewy on the inside, almost like if they where microwaved. The chicken sandwich wasn’t good either all I got was spinach flavor no seasoning, overall no good. The pizza was ok if the buffalo chicken wasn’t so chewy either, why is everything there so chewy and over priced. Now everyone says the customer service is amazing, guess I just go on bad days, bc everyone always has a nasty face. No smile no nothing, like they are being forced to be there. Crazy because every time I go there’s no one so I’d expect to be in and out but somehow the person coming in 5 minutes after me is still leaving before me (yes with a bigger order) just dosent make sense. Overall the box says best pizza in Brooklyn 2020. Time to change the box bro. I could get better cheese sticks and beef patties in the deli across...