Brooklyn Diner USA
Brooklyn Diner USA things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
What to Eat During a Week in New York
DobbinDobbin
920
I got the 15 bite hot dog. While I didn't like the price it certainly filled me up....and it took me more than 15 bites. I hear it's 1 pound and it certainly looks like it. I was not a fan of the fries because they taste like they dust them with corn starch to make them crispy. The arugula salad was good and I wish it came with more. I came about an hour and a half before closing and got seated as soon as I got there. The waiters were friendly. The diner has that old school vibe and the seating is tiny. I came with a backpack and it barely fit with me in the bench booth and I'm skinny. 2 people seated together in a larger booth are basically touching shoulder to shoulder (without bags). The waiter saw that I finished everything and asked me if I wanted some extra fries. I thought that was nice. After I paid he also told me to come again. The price of my meal at the time of writing this was $26.08. Plus, I left a tip.
CL GCL G
00
As I already mentioned, in NYC, any tourist looks for the "Diner experience"... We all want to go to a diner that looks like the ones we see in the movies. But it turns out there are very few of them in the city. So we had to ask around and we were sent to Brooklyn Diner USA. From the outside it is what we expect from a diner. From the inside too, even though it's probably more chic than what we were looking for. We went for brunch and we were told that we didn't need to book in advance. I don't know if they take bookings anyway... but we had to wait in the cold for 30 minutes, which is not so pleasant. Once inside, the service was diligent. Each one of us had a different dish but all of them looked very austere (except maybe the French toasts): the pancakes, for instance, felt really alone in the middle of the plate... Everything was good but nothing was memorable... until we got the check: $120 for 3 dishes for brunch! I know NYC is expensive but this is another level! 😤 I said before the diner looked chic but it still was chaotic and very noisy. At some point, they even turned the music up so that any conversation became impossible. At that point we just asked for the check and left. That was not a pleasant experience... 😥 Quality & taste: 7/10 Quantities: 8/10 Atmosphere: 5/10 Originality: 4/10 Ratio price / quality: 3/10 Service: 7/10 How I felt afterwards: 4/10 More on IG @runnerandfoodie
Mathieu MuraccioleMathieu Muracciole
00
If anyone asks me after this trip what a must do event is in NYC my response is going to be "Go to Brooklyn Diner and get a PotPie." Hopefully they get the chance to meet Guy and Jen because they made it such an unforgettable experience. Just genuinely friendly and lovely people. They talked to us a bit about the history of the place and had a bunch of cool knowledge. The food was amazing and I'll be thinking about the pot pie for a long time. The crust was so flaky and it had huge huge chunks of tender chicken. I couldn't believe how amazing it was. The 15-bite hotdog was crispy and garlicy. If you get it PUT THE SALAD ON IT! TASTY. BTW a side of fries IS HUGE! The service was amazing, the lively atmosphere is fantastic. The speed of service is great not a huge wait despite being a big crowd the first day we went. We loved it so much we went twice!!!! Honestly can't wait to make another trip to NYC.
Deejay PandaDeejay Panda
00
I came here for dinner with a friend yesterday. It’s an American diner, with authentic diner vibes with booth style seating and the food is incredible. It has such an amazing vibe that even when my friend and I were done eating we spent hours just talking and enjoying the comforting atmosphere! The staff was SO KIND truly amazing, they were attentive to every person and just so welcoming. Especially Gen!! She was so kind, had an amazing conversation with her. And not to mention my phone was dying and it was my only way to go home & she was kind enough to charge it throughout my entire dinner, she was truly an unmatched soul. The food was amazing and aesthetic, so absolutely perfect for pictures throughout the night. Just a lovely place to go with loved ones and have amazing conversations. I will DEFINITELY be going back.💗 If you’re in the area you have to check it out.
Kitty LorenzoKitty Lorenzo
00
I had just finished the United New Yock Half Marathon so we wanted to find a place to decompress and refuel. With the number of people in the area and being a Sunday, everywhere was packed. The Brooklyn Diner was no different. We were told about 20/30 minutes, a little less than most places, so we put our names on the list. It didn’t take that long and we were taken to our table. Pro-tip, make a reservation. Unfortunately, it was Sunday and 10:00 am so we were not able to get a drink. After a long cold race, and the early morning start, we were a little disappointed. That is not their fault, just wanted to make a note so you can plan your brunch. The menu has classic diner food. I had the Pastrami Hash and my wife had the Yogurt/fruit/granola bowl. Mine was a classic hash with runny eggs on top. The polenta cakes on the side were a little odd, but they were good.
Brian ParkerBrian Parker
00
Nearby Attractions Of Brooklyn Diner USA
Times Square
Rockefeller Center
Top of The Rock
The Museum of Modern Art
M&M'S New York
St. Patrick's Cathedral
Radio City Music Hall
Central Park Zoo
Apple Fifth Avenue
Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts

Times Square
4.7
(66.7K)Click for details

Rockefeller Center
4.7
(57.3K)Click for details

Top of The Rock
4.7
(22.6K)Click for details

The Museum of Modern Art
4.6
(19.5K)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Brooklyn Diner USA
Ellen's Stardust Diner
Junior's Restaurant & Bakery
Junior's Restaurant and Bakery
Gallaghers Steakhouse
La Grande Boucherie
Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center
Tavern On the Green
Bill's Bar & Burger
Havana Central Times Square
Broad Nosh Bagels Deli & Catering 58th Street

Ellen's Stardust Diner
4.4
(8K)Click for details

Junior's Restaurant & Bakery
4.4
(5.5K)Click for details

Junior's Restaurant and Bakery
4.4
(4.9K)Click for details

Gallaghers Steakhouse
4.6
(3.3K)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
212 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019
Map
Phone
(212) 977-1957
Call
Website
brooklyndiner.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.3
(1.9K reviews)
Ratings & Description
Description
Set near Carnegie Hall, this nostalgic high-end diner offers both classic & creative dishes.
attractions: Times Square, Rockefeller Center, Top of The Rock, The Museum of Modern Art, M&M'S New York, St. Patrick's Cathedral, Radio City Music Hall, Central Park Zoo, Apple Fifth Avenue, Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts, restaurants: Ellen's Stardust Diner, Junior's Restaurant & Bakery, Junior's Restaurant and Bakery, Gallaghers Steakhouse, La Grande Boucherie, Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center, Tavern On the Green, Bill's Bar & Burger, Havana Central Times Square, Broad Nosh Bagels Deli & Catering 58th Street

- Please manually select your location for better experience