Mex Carroll's Diner — Restaurant in New York

Reviews are all over the place on Mex Carroll's Diner. Can tell you this though, our meals were definitely 5 stars. Didn't look at the reviews before going here and glad we didn't as we might have passed it up. We were meeting with an attorney nearby and when we left we asked her about it. She noted she has eaten there many times and it was very good. She also mentioned it was a "Mexican Diner". Didn't quite grasped what was meant by this, but when we got the menu we understood. Whoa, tremendous menu. Over 20 different types of omelettes, 7 different eggs benedict variations, at least twenty different burger styles, pasta dishes, etc. Something for everyone. Never knew something like a "Mexican Diner" existed. Nice concept.

As mentioned previously our meals were 5 star. The same could be said for the service and dining atmosphere. We ate outside in their backyard courtyard. Pleasantly decorated and comfortable. Surrounded by greenery and most of the tables had large umbrellas to keep the sun from beaming down on you. No issues with the service provide by the wait staff. On our way out we were wished a good a good day. We had brunch which was an order of Huevos Rancheros and Eggs Benedict. Had a choice of red or green salsa to go with the Huevos Rancheros. Went with the green which was perfect. Not too spicy, but not bland either. It came with refried beans and yellow rice. Both were a delight. Ordered a fresh squeezed orange juice that was as fresh squeezed should be...in other words really good. Mexican Diner with tons of Mexican breakfast choices and what does my wife order...Eggs Benedict! Well, I guess that's the point of a diner. Lots of choices. Verdict on the Eggs Benedict was a thumbs up. Very good with no complaints.

BTW...Might have to put some of the one star reviews in context. One person left a one star because they wouldn't let him use the bathroom. Just came in off the street and wasn't going to order anything. Really? Also there are complaints about the prices. We thought they were reasonable especially considering the portion size. Check out the menu...

Coming in to this place one can't help but notice and feel the very friendly staff. As soon as I walked in I was greeted with a big smile and hello, perhaps for some that's not very important but for someone like me, it just adds more to the experience. The inside is very nice with nice seating and spacious. One also has the option to sit out in the patio, which is something I didn't think could be nice, but as I stepped outside I was left mesmerized as they have a very nice space and a garden. Now on to the food, the food was really good, they always have breakfast anytime which is great as I like to get my breakfast around late in the afternoon. They have a Mexican corner in the menu, and quite frankly it was very good! I tried the steak tacos, and they were tasty, they come in three, and the best part is they are authentic Mexican tacos, just the more better. All in all, this place is definitely something I would recommend...

My wife and I went here for the first time this morning. We walked in to and empty restaurant. They sat us and handed us the menu. We were looking at the menu for no more than 3-5 minutes before I hear the manager say in Spanish what these people need more than 30 minutes to order? The hostess laughs along with the comment. I'm an Argentine/Ecuadorian that speaks fluent Spanish. I understood this whole exchange and became extremely irritated and told my wife I didn't feel comfortable eating there . So we left . Running a restaurant that seems to be empty you should do everything possible to make your customers feel happy and welcome to repeat business and to spread word of a good restaurant. We regularly eat breakfast and like to find new places but this location is somewhere I definitely will never...