Rocky's & Nicky's — Restaurant in New York

Cheese is fine, sauce is meh, crust is meh. That's for a cheese slice. If you get pepperoni I swear it's like there's no cheese underneath the meat; they go very skimpy.

It is unfortunate I have to rate them so low, as this is the closest place to us. Between the mediocre pizza and the terrible service, I just won't go back here again. It's never been great but - because of proximity - my family used to eat here once every quarter. We MUCH prefer Bella Roma on 3rd for my counter slice itch.

My last experience was the final straw. First, my husband handed the guy a $20 on a $7 order and the man just gave him back $10. Like, he literally gave himself to a $3 tip. We ordered 2 boring slices and when we got home and opened the box my slice had napkins melted into the top; it was paper fused with cheese, no picking it off. Inedible. So I walk myself back to the place with the untouched slice and they have the audacity to argue with me about it. Tried to say maybe I did it. Seriously? They survive because they get foot traffic from the park and the pier, but they really shouldn't still be in business with so many other decent places...

Single handedly the worst slice I've ever eaten. I feel sorry for those whose live here and must endure this pizza and call it good. It was reminiscent of a burnt grilled cheese, except the school lunch edition. So heavily burnt I could have thrown it to break the window of their store as this slice did to my heart as I had to receive this prison meal into my body. No trace of sauce was left on my slice, as it was mostly likely recycled from the day before or baked a few times already I would imagine, leaving my tastebuds to choke it down with the room temperature ginger ale I purchased from them despite being in the refrigerator which clearly was not working. I suggest you find a different place to bring your friends and family if you live around here and are trying to impress them with the New York's finest slice. I've made better frozen pizza whilst drunk than what I...

Thinnest slices you can find, and they're soggy. Failing business, they overcharge and underdeliver. Take a walk for a better slice, it'll be worth your money, if even for an up to date menu and/or the ability to order online. People go here because they don't have much of a choice. It's pizza, deli food or sushi. Whole business strip kind of sucks to be honest.

Avoid ordering online at all, the menu has lower prices on it so they always mark the food "ready" WAY before it's ready and everyone else is correct about the main guy being a macho a** when you give online ordering a chance. "Just call next time, don't give me headaches" Definitely won't be getting any more...