Rosa's Pizza — Restaurant in New York

I eat pizza almost every day. I’ve eaten at hundreds of pizzerias over the years but just stumbled upon this place about two years ago. WOW! Everything here is excellent. The sauce on their pizza is amazing. Not every pizza is good cold. Theirs is. I’ll take two slices home with me and eat them at room temperature and it’s just as delicious as fresh out of the oven. I’ll take pies home and freeze them two slices per zip lock because I live 25 miles away. I have 9 pizzerias within five miles of my home yet I won’t hesitate to travel the 25 miles for excellent quality pizza and service from this place. I’ve written many reviews and I always read other people’s opinions as well. I’ve never experienced anything but professionalism and friendly service from these people, that’s why I was shocked to read some of the negative reviews. I can walk in there and order a pie and watch it being made and walk out with it in about 8 minutes. Look at the cheese pie I’m posting on this review. Got it at 12:30 AM today to take out. So delicious!😋. I recommend that anyone who truly loves pizza 🍕 should try this place. I’m a simple guy when it comes to pizza (regular or Sicilian) but I notice other patrons eating all kinds of varieties of their pizza and loving it. My recommendation is to put Rosa’s of fresh pond on your bucket list…..if you’re a true...

This restaurant has some of the worst customer treatment I have ever seen. I was there today at about 1:00 PM when I saw the workers wrongfully yelling at a kid and wouldn’t give him his garlic knots as he was simply just asking about them. I saw that the kid paid for the garlic knots and when he came to ask for them, they told him there was nothing in the oven and thus denied to give him any. It wasn’t until everyone gathered around that they finally decided to give him the food, pretending as if they were just doing him a favor and told him verbatim “take the garlic knots and get the hell out of the restaurant” in the rudest tone possible. The owner then proceeded to say that he has the right not to serve us and when asked why, he responded by saying “because I don’t to.”

As we kept asking why, he then went to come and forcefully push my friend out of the store, thus putting his hands on him when my friend didn’t touch him at all. Not to mention, this wasn’t just a one time thing but rather an on-going weekly problem for the same group of kids. We all go to Rosa’s together every week on Sunday’s after church and end up getting harassed every single time, despite buying food and profiting their place. This restaurant has shown nothing but blatant disrespect and harassment to us and I definitely wouldn’t recommend...

I love Rosa’s Pizza here on Fresh Pond Road. I’ve been coming here all throughout my childhood and I continue to come back whenever I can. The pizza is the best because it’s fresh and delicious. There are always people in here buying it, so they have a quick turnover. My mom used to bring me their eggplant roll when she would come to school to do lunch duty for me at Our Lady of Hope. I still love their eggplant rolls and the others as well. I love ordering the little marinara sauce with it so I can pour some on to it.

Their rolls can also be made without cheese. While I love cheese for most, they do a spinach roll that I love without the cheese. You can order it ahead of time for pickup. I always judge a pizzeria by their plain slice and theirs is the best and my favorite. I also love their Margherita slice, chicken tomato, the grandma slice, taco slice if I’m starving lol and so many more. This place has my heart and all of my cravings! I’m literally going back to get a few other things for home as well. I’ve scoured my phone for Rosa’s pizza photos, as I’ve been here plenty throughout my childhood...