Sunny John Pizzeria — Restaurant in New York

I started off with giving this place 3 stars because I thought the food was decent,no better or worse then some of the others around. It looks clean so that's definitely a big positive. But then I decided to take away a half star for the fact that whenever I go in there to order, it seems they have so many regulars during the day, that even if you're at the counter first and a regular walks in behind you they want to take care of them before you. I thought it was first come first serve. I decided that instead of being a grumpy old pain in the backside that I would order delivery. After one or two occasions where I placed an order for delivery. The food was not only lukewarm at best when i live less than two blocks from the pizza shop. I get one of these delivery drivers that can never just hand you your change. Instead I get the question. How much you want back?! Really!! Is this dude for real?? Is there something wrong with handing a customer back their change & waiting to see if they feel you deserve a tip. I myself tip almost 90% of the time regardless. But to try and shame a customer into getting one self a tip is not only tacky and shows no class, it is improper etiquette. So with all that has happened in the past. When I placed an order for delivery today & was told that i was $1.50 short of the delivery minimum of $15.00. So you should order something else. I was at a loss for words for about 5 seconds. All the places that I've ordered takeout from within a block or two of this place. All others minimum or not ,waived it when they decided that customer was less than 2 blocks from them. To take a loss of $14.50 just to quibble over $.50 from a customer who has come to you repeatedly, time and time again that's sad but I hope they find solace in sticking to their beliefs. Another half star gone!! So to end...In the words of Lauren Hill "You might win some, but you just...

This pizzeria was our go to when we were kids. They were in the location across the street next to what once was sunny dale. Everyday after school my friends and I would go to sunny johns grab a slice and a coke for 1.25, then get quarter drinks and chips next door and headed to Utica park to play hours of handball. Amazing memories. 💕 Unfortunately yesterday was the next time I ate in well over 20 yrs. It was just as good, if not better than I remembered. I love that they have some of the same celebrity photos hanging up from the old place. I am happy for them getting a bigger space and it is well decorated. Food was delicious and atmosphere was quiet and clean. It saddens me that I don't live closer to frequent this...

What an amazing small/big business they have here!!!!! I flew in from Chicago at 1115am, ride to the pizza place was 40 minutes but I didn’t mind because it’s 5min away from my Airbnb! Welp, the owner was really nice and the staff was really fast and effective. So nice that they allowed me to wait in their establishment till my Airbnb was available at 3! Did I tell you the pizza 🍕 was REALLY GOOD! Light and really thin! Loved 🥰 it. So it’s 1:47p and my Airbnb is ready!!!!! Let me order this LARGE CHEESE!!!!!! I AM EXHAUSTED but loving the...