The Square on Annadale — Restaurant in New York

Very good square slices. Only problem is delivery takes a very long time. Edited10/8/21. If I could give this place 0 stars I would. Used to be a good place but after what happened to me tonight I’d say if you have their menu throw it in the nearest garbage can. At 5:45 I placed an order over the phone for a square pie and a spaghetti with meat sauce after well over 1 hour I called and was told he was on his way well when the driver finally showed up I was given the wrong order! I called the store and was told she’d send the driver back 1/2 later he still wasn’t here at that point I called the store and told them I just want my money back for the spaghetti which wasn’t delivered I kept calling every 1/2 hour and was spoken to so rudely as though it was my fault and they kept telling me they were to busy to come and return my money! They had to be kidding me! It took until almost 10 PM for someone to come give me my money and when I attempted to ask for some sort of compensation the rude girl told me they have bills to pay and they couldn’t do anything for me. I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THEM AGAIN and neither should...

As a loyal customer of Square Pizzeria for years, I can confidently say that this place never disappoints. Their menu is a delightful mix of flavors, but a few items stand out that I can't resist!

First up, the Buffalo Chicken Rolls are absolutely phenomenal! The perfect blend of spicy buffalo chicken wrapped in a crispy exterior makes for an irresistible appetizer or a satisfying snack.

Then there's the Grandma Pizza – it's a slice of heaven! The thin crust, rich tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella come together in a way that reminds me of classic Italian cooking. Each bite is bursting with flavor, and it’s always cooked to perfection.

Let’s not forget about their meatballs. These are some of the best I've ever had! Juicy, flavorful, and made with the perfect blend of spices, they pair wonderfully with their marinara sauce.

Whether you’re dining in or ordering out, Square Pizzeria is a must-try. Their consistent quality and delicious offerings keep me coming back for more....

I am from North Jersey and I was visiting my friend Michelle in S.I. we ordered from The Square 2x times and both times were very good and the service was excellent. We had ordered their square pizza which was out of this world better then Jersey pizza! And we have order their Cheesesteak wrap and they were able to accommodate our special request. In addition, we have ordered their Rice Ball specialty which was absolutely amazing! The customer service from online ordering and a call came from Stacy who was extremely friendly and double checking our order. I call that old school service which was amazing! I highly recommend this place to anyone!

I did not rate the atmosphere, due to that I never been to the actual place,...