Tony's Brick Oven — Restaurant in New York

If you're craving authentic Italian food on the North Shore of Staten Island, Tony's Brick Oven is the place to go! I've been coming here for years, and every visit is just as satisfying as the last. From St. George to Tompkinsville, Clifton, Stapleton, Grymes Hill, and Silver Lake, anyone nearby needs to make this their go-to pizza and Italian spot.

Their brick oven pizza is unmatched—that perfect charred crust, fresh mozzarella, and house-made sauce really make every slice unforgettable. My personal favorites are the Margherita Pizza, Grandpa Pie, and Buffalo Chicken slice. But honestly, you can't go wrong with anything on the menu.

I highly recommend their Penne Vodka with Shrimp, Angel Hair in White Clam Sauce, and Chicken Francaise. The Eggplant Rollatini and Chicken Cacciatore are also absolutely delicious. And don't even think about leaving without trying the garlic knots or antipasto salad.

They even have gluten-free options and the best vodka sauce in Staten Island hands down. Whether you dine in, grab takeout, or get delivery, the quality is always spot on.

The staff is friendly, the service is great, and the atmosphere makes you feel like family. Plus, it's just minutes from the Staten Island Ferry, which makes it super convenient if you're near zip codes 10301, 10304, 10305, 10302, or 10310.

Tony's Brick Oven has been a staple for over 20 years, and there's a reason why. If you're on Staten Island's North Shore, do yourself a favor and stop by—you won't be...

Did not specify on their website that the Tony's special pizza came with any particular toppings on it pre-customization so we ordered it with just pepperoni selected, and it came with a whole bunch of other toppings, including something someone in our household was allergic to. When we explained this to an employee over the phone, the guy immediately asked if we ordered online like this sort of thing happens all the time and said that's just how the Tony's special pizza comes, despite the site saying nothing regarding those toppings coming on the pizza. He was completely blasé and unapologetic about it, and said there was nothing they could do about it. It's completely reckless to have undisclosed toppings when ordering pizza from your website, I don't care if it's an understood thing amongst some of your customers that the Tony's special pizza denotes certain toppings. You can't just not list the other toppings that are gonna be on the pizza, especially if you give us the option to select all your usual toppings to add onto it like it's a blank pizza! Extremely disappointed, my family has had great experiences ordering in the past but a blasé, dismissive attitude about undisclosed allergens are a hard...

I wanted to place an order for pick up. A gentleman answers the phone. I say hello I want to place an order for pick up. I say I want a Margherita but Sicilian. He answers me we don’t have a margherita Sicilian. A margherita is a round pie. Now, correct me if I am wrong but why can’t you make the pie in a square. The same way you would make the margherita in a circle? It obviously shows my ignorance with the type of pizzas they offer. Instead of trying to insult a potential customer and say out right we don’t have that. I said the menu online says the same ingredients as a margherita. I figured I tell him margherita sicilian because I didn’t want a traditional thick Sicilian. Then I said let me look on the menu. And the same ingredients are on the Sicilian as the margherita. I guess in his mind a margherita style can only be round and not Sicilian. It totally baffled me that he couldn’t just have taken my order. I had to hang up and not order and I won’t ever order from there again. I rather drive across the...