Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen — Restaurant in New York

I saw the tiktok video made by the owner and immediately added this place to my must try list. So happy I did!

The cupcakes I got were AMAZING. They were light, buttery, soooo soft, and not too sweet (even the cream topping). I can not even stress how much I was impressed with the cupcakes. I went about 45 mins before they closed and was not expecting the quality to be that fresh as if they just made them for me!

I am absolutely not a matcha person but the team there talked me into trying the vanilla matcha cupcake and omg! Yes, yes, get the cupcake! It was sooo good. None of the overwhelming bitter flavors you normally get with matcha. This is not a trick to secretly make you try grass, I swear, get the matcha strawberry or vanilla cupcakes, they were both excellent.

And to the star of the show....the banana pudding. I got it after another customer in the shop said it was really good. I ordered a tray so that I could share with my family. That was a big mistake. I want to preface this by saying I've had Magnolia's banana pudding and was so disappointed. It was not worth the hype in my opinion so I was skeptical about this one. When I got back to the car, I decided to try the banana pudding before going to my mum's house and regretted it. It was soooo good, I was questioning why I had agreed to share; why had I stupidly already told them I was bringing it. I was strongly considering telling them that they had to go get their own. One bite turned into me taking more bites to "even it out" and before I knew it, a third of the tray was gone. 😭 I didn't even realize I was eating a lot because like the cupcakes, the banana pudding is so light and flavorful and never got to the point of giving me that sticky sweet feeling when you eat too much sugary stuff.

I don't know what they put in their recipes here but like the matcha, I don't even like bananas that much and now I'm stressed that this review will have people buying all of it and there won't be any left for me 😭😅

Please go support.....but also like...

Yummy Tummy Kitchen is a must-visit in Brooklyn, NY (Williamsburg)! This Black woman-owned bakery serves up homemade treats that are perfectly balanced—not too sweet, just pure deliciousness.

I had the chocolate chip cookie, crisp on the edges, soft in the center, and packed with melty chocolate. The vanilla cupcake with whipped icing was light, moist, and topped with silky, not-too-sweet frosting. The homemade banana pudding was smooth, creamy, and layered with fresh bananas and vanilla wafers—comforting and full of flavor.

On top of the amazing treats, the owner, Melissa, was incredibly kind, professional, and very knowledgeable about the products, making the experience even more enjoyable. Every bite was memorable, and best of all, I was left feeling satisfied, not stuffed. If you love high-quality, handcrafted sweets, stop by Yummy Tummy—you...

Birthdays. Weddings. Funerals. If I care about the people I'm serving, I'm ordering dessert from Yummy Tummy's. And if I hate them, I'm still ordering from here so I can taunt them with it while keeping it all to myself ;)

Melissa is phenomenal - a born talent. I just feel lucky to have found her before the line is reaching around the block. Everything she makes tastes incredible. My current favorites are the seasonal pumpkin spice & sweet potato cheesecakes, but I've been working my way through her menu, and I've loved everything.

Also have to agree with the other reviewers that her banana pudding is just ridiculously delicious. Like, stupid good and I really mean that because I hate bananas in most iterations. But her pudding is...