Ordered for the first time last night. I work very close to this restaurant and smell it every night, couldn’t wait to try it. I definitely liked it but didn’t love it 😩 I ordered the fisherman’s boat with fisherman’s chips and a Caesar salad. I have to say the calamari was the worst I’ve ever had in my life. It felt like all I was eating were the crunchy pieces from the bottom of the basket. Super disappointed. The salad was basically half of a lettuce head with a few croutons. I wouldn’t order those 2 things again. EVERYTHING else in the meal was great. Flavorful and the portions were filling. That meal costs about $33. My husband got the cod/shrimp meal with fisherman’s chips and coleslaw. He said the coleslaw was very dry and had no flavor. Other than that he said his meal was great and filling. His meal was about $22. The tartar sauce is really good. I ordered online- easy and quick. My food was piping hot and ready at exactly my pickup time. We will eat here again just choose our sides...
Read moreThere wasn't a host or a sign at the patio entrance so at first we were confused if we were supposed to wait to be seated or seat ourselves. Then a waitress told us that the left side was full service and the right side was counter service, but we could sit anywhere (still confusing for first timers). There were 2 or 3 menus which mostly looked similar, but there were some differences (again, confusing). Our server had to explain the specials to us and point out the difference in menus. We finally ordered fish and shrimp tacos (after reading good reviews on them), but sadly were disappointed. There was barely any flavor- just bland sauce, fish, and lettuce/cabbage with no sauce on it. We had to ask for salsa or hot sauce. The 2 tacos were decent in size, but the potatoes wedges were nothing special, the margarita was super sour, and overall it was not a good experience. The server was super friendly and efficient, but other than that, it's just a chain restaurant in...
Read moreI have previously been to the Fisherman's Grill in P.S. and when a friend suggested lunch and I also wanted to go to Trader Joes, I thought " fish". We sat inside and ordered at the counter, just a few minutes and our food came. I ordered the Baja tacos with fries and my gf had Mahi Mahi tacos with Cole slaw. When I picked up my taco I realized that many of the fries had been integrated into the tacos and they looked exactly like the fish. (Sorry forgot to snap pix). The fish was at the bottom and it took eating all the "fry taco" before I got to the fish part. There were only 2 small pieces of fish in each and there was also a lot of sauce ( sort of tartar sauce), so unfortunately I was quite disappointed. I should have gone to the manager but I wasn't feeling well and didn't want to do anything but go home. I will try again to see if I have a better experience I must say there were a lot of good looking options in the BIG blackboard to...
Read more