Peachtree City Yacht Club — Restaurant in Peachtree City

Eh. It wasn't great. Our fish came out super rubbery, we had to send it back. The collard greens were weird, they have a really sweet taste to them which was strange to me. The mac n cheese tastes exactly like mac n cheese from KFC. It wasn't good. The fried pickles had a really thick batter on them and not much flavor to the batter but the actual pickle tasted good. We ordered a cold shrimp cocktail, the first time it came out warm, sent it back, it came back out somewhat cold but it was a shrimp cocktail and it was peel and eat shrimp and the shrimp was incredibly rubbery. We order the child's hamburger for our son, it was cooked so well done that it was crispy all except a quarter sized area in the center. He wouldn't eat it after taking one bite.

Pros; the blackened trigger fish was really good and their hushpuppies are good. Our server, who resembled Post Malone without the face tattoos, was exceptional. He's a hustler and did a great job! Very good waiter and very attentive.

I love seafood but we definitely didn't have a good experience. Maybe it's that they're so new or are so incredibly busy, I don't know but my bill was over $130 for the two of us and our son and we were disappointed in the majority of the food. Post, our waiter, made it a lot more pleasant fun doing such a great job, my bills usually run on the high side anywhere we go eat, we usually order a lot of things when we eat out, I didn't like feeling so disappointed with a bill that high for 2 people. The food should have been exceptional but was subpar at best. I don't know that we'll give it another chance or not, there's Due South which is seafood now and Frank's at the Old Mill which does Oysters and seafood amazingly. I was hoping they'd be incredible, I'd love a really, really great restaurant actually in Peachtree City, especially a seafood restaurant that does amazing oysters. That would be great...

If I wrote this review at face value, My initial impression would be far lower than a four-star rating, however, the manager this evening is the sole reason why ill not only will be give this place another shot, but giving a 4 star review right now. Our server, obviously inexperienced and young, but also appeared to lack work ethic, attention, and hustle. Every other server in the restaurant happily greeted their tables, gave great recommendations, wore a smile, and jumped to attend their patrons. Our server was slow, didn't have much ambition to assist us, and had to be reminded of literally all our orders; drinks, appetizer, and our meal. We waited 50 minutes for a table, then waited 15 minutes for a drink. Ultimately, over an hour passed before I finally asked when our meal would arrive and at that time we were made aware that they had forgotten to put our food order in and it would be ready in 10-15 minutes. By this time, the table of four to our left and right, who were sat about 15 minutes after we were, were nearly finished with their meals. I expressed my concern to the manager and he expressed his apologies. In addition, he comp'd our meal which was not expected but greatly appreciated. Regardless of our initial impressions of this restaurant, the manager's professionalism and the quality of food we received was fantastic. We are looking forward to our next visit and if it goes anything like the tables to the left or right of us, I expect to update this review to a...

I’m so glad we noticed this place!!! We’re in the area weekly for karate with our daughter and have never paid attention to what’s in the plaza!!! Well, last night we were wanting to celebrate her belt promotion and googled restaurants in the area, we are from Miami and LOVE SEAFOOD, so after reading a few reviews, we decided if it wasn’t crowded we would give it a try! Sooooo happy we did!! Ryan was our server and he was so nice!!! Now the food…EVERYTHING WAS GOOD!! We didn’t even get pictures of the appetizer cause we ate it so fast! We got the firecracker shrimp, and it’s hot hot, but delicious and you can still taste the shrimp through the heat!! I got the whole fried snapper and omg…..it was fried to perfection and soooo well seasoned!!! We also ordered the fried platter for two, it’s got fish, shrimp, clam strips, oysters and fries and it’s enough for three or possibly four people to eat!! The red beans and rice were yummy!! The hush puppies were even good!!! We also got fresh oysters and they tasted fresh and oceany like I like them!! Our daughter got shrimp and fries and she was delighted by how crispy the fries were!!! We’ve decided this is our spot now so we will get to try just about everything cause I’ll order something different each...