The Brother's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Pooler

Absolutely terrible experience. This has to be one of the worst pizza places I’ve ever been to.

Let’s start with the pizza—it was unbelievably thin, like eating a soggy cracker with barely any toppings. There was so little to it that I genuinely felt like I hadn’t eaten anything. The crust was just as bad: tough in some spots, weirdly chewy in others, and just overall unpleasant. Worst of all, the flavor was completely lacking. Bland, forgettable, and honestly, kind of sad.

Then there was the service. The staff seemed annoyed from the moment we walked in. Plates were slammed onto our table like we had somehow offended them just by ordering. Not a single napkin was given to us, and any time we asked for something, it felt like we were bothering them. Super unprofessional and rude.

The place itself didn’t help. The fridges were completely empty—which was strange and gave the place an odd, abandoned vibe. And to top it all off, one of the chairs literally broke while I was sitting in it. No apology, no help, just awkward stares from the staff.

Overall, just a horrible experience from start to finish. Would...

Been here for a week and tried a different restaurant every night and this was by far the best we went to. The inside is adorable and very cozy, loved the music playing. The lady that took our order was so sweet and joked around with us. Everything we got was delicious and came out fast. I ordered a large pizza while my fiancé ordered a medium and we were very surprised when his pizza came out first and it was the size i was expecting for my large pizza. We obviously weren’t the only ones who liked their food as they had people in and out the door the entire time we were there. We were able to sit and eat there but takeout is also a fast option from what i saw while we were there. I recommend the white pizza with added spinach...

This is the best pizza I’ve had in our entire region. It is the closest match to authentic, Northern-style pizza in our area. I tried to take a picture that shows how it’s seasoned to perfection and insanely flavorful. High quality ingredients and freshly made. The food is AMAZING, the prices are great, but the customer service is always fantastic. There is always a beautiful smile and kind demeanor waiting at the counter. I have never left disappointed and I’ve been going there for many, many years. You have to give...