New York Pizza of Redlands — Restaurant in Redlands

Me and my partner decided to try this place out here for lunch. Despite the strange choice of seating and dirty dining areas. Also dirty trays that have been sitting on the table from people who have been long gone. We decided to share a small pizza for lunch. A small meat lovers to be specific. And for some reason it was 15 dollars. The man was not friendly. And ignored me every time I told him “thank you” The atmosphere and ambiance was very uncomfortable and awkward. Just because of how unwelcoming his attitude was. A woman came out and handed us plates and a fork, and was also ignored by her when I said thank you. About 15 minutes later we received our pizza. And let me tell you about this pizza. It was the size of a personal pizza that they used to sell at targets. 4 small slices.

The sauce and meat was unmemorable, but I’ll give him an extra star for how good his crust was. That is all. I wasted 15 dollars. I wasted time. Left hungry and annoyed....

Excellent food with high quality ingredients! Great owner!

Get it your way! Dine In... Get it To-Go... Order Ahead... or, Have It Delivered!

It's a local favorite with a loyal fan base. A common statement I hear customers say is... "Great as always."

I'm currently eating my way through the menu. Everything I've had has been fantastic! It's easy to just order a pizza and stop at that because they're so good. But, I recommend you also keep trying other items on the menu. Hot Pastrami sandwich, Calzone, and the New York Cheese Steak sandwich are all to to die for. Party trays too!

The owner is the epitome of small town hospitality, taking pride in providing excellent food and truly appreciates...

Looked this place up through Google. I wanted pizza but was tired of all the corporate pizza businesses around here. So my husband and I decided to give them a chance. And boy am I glad we did. We got a large pizza with pepperoni and sausage with light sauce, mild wings and an anti pasta salad. Everything was BOMB!! We found out that they deliver up to 18 mile and will be doing deliver next. This is our new pizza place...no more Lityle Ceasar or Pizza Hit for us. The one thing I loved about this place is its family owned. The service was very pleasant, we even saw the husband (the owner) help a customer out with their order to her car. Try it and you won't be...