I love custard and was excited to try Whitâs. I went with the strawberry shortcake sundae, which I ate in store and took home a pint of the key lime pie, one of my absolute favorite flavors. The strawberry shortcake sundae was amazing! I will definitely come back for it again. The key lime pie was a little disappointing (hence 4 stars and not 5). It didnât have enough key lime flavor. I would have liked it better if the flavor was kicked up a notch. Key lime lovers want to be hit with key lime.
I had a good experience overall though. The employees worked through the line quickly and were very friendly. I felt like the prices were reasonable and in line with what custard typically costs. I also love the daily flavor calendar and that they have some of those previous flavors in pints and quarts to take home. I would definitely...
   Read moreFor a month straight⌠I sent my husband all of Whits IG post to put it on his radar. Instead of an extravagant steak dinner on our anniversary I just wanted WHITS⌠the day comes and we go in for the first time and immediately you can tell On our faces we had trouble deciding on one of the many options. A very sweet guy named Nick came around the corner with samples to help with our decisions⌠immediately sold with the 2 scoop option, one waffle caramel crunch and one red velvet⌠and by very little convincing needed we grabbed some Whitties too! Needless to say we will be back, weekly! Nick and his wife were extremely nice and went way over above and beyond to make my little simple request on my anniversary the best treat Iâve ever had. 10/10 I will always...
   Read moreStaff was very polite and friendly. The problem with this place is that they pile the ice cream into an open cup, then pile it higher than the rim, and then they don't cover it; so everything that's above the rim of the cup immediately melts into your hands, crotch, car seat, etc. I made it from the front door to my car in the parking lot before the container started dumping melted ice cream all over everything. I got frustrated and threw it away, having only taken about two bites before I had to stop eating and start wiping up all the melted ice cream everywhere, which caused more of it to melt, which spilled more, which caused more wiping. Not worth the hassle to shop here, there's plenty of other ice cream shops around that offer...
   Read more