Antigoni’s Pizza — Restaurant in Scarborough

I stopped in last week, hungry for something simple and good. The pizza delivered. The crust had that light crackle when you bite in, yet it stayed chewy toward the center. I went for the Mediterranean topping combo: fresh tomatoes, briny olives, a whisper of oregano, and just-melted feta that didn’t drown the other flavors. Every slice felt balanced, not heavy.

Because a friend swears by their salads, I added the Caesar. Glad I did. Crisp romaine, shaved Parm, and a dressing that tasted house-made—bright with lemon and anchored by real anchovy depth. Bonus: crunchy, warm croutons that actually tasted like bread, not cardboard.

Service stayed relaxed but attentive. They checked in once, topped up waters, and let us linger. Prices felt fair for the quality and portions; I left full without that too-stuffed regret.

If you’re after a place where the pizza crust matters and the Caesar salad isn’t an afterthought, Antigoni’s is...

Antigoni’s Pizza is one of those places you walk into once — and instantly know you’ll be back. I went in expecting good pizza, but what I got was a full-on Mediterranean experience. The food is fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care.

Their pizza is amazing — the crust is perfectly crispy, the toppings are generous, and the flavors are bold without being overwhelming. I had one with feta and fresh veggies, and it seriously tasted like something right out of a Greek kitchen. And it’s not just pizza — the salads are super fresh, the subs are loaded, and everything just hits the spot.

The staff is warm and friendly, the kind of place where they greet you with a smile and genuinely seem happy you’re there. You can tell this is a local favorite — and now I see why.

If you're into Mediterranean food or just love fresh, honest cooking, give Antigoni’s a try. Whether you’re eating in or ordering online, you won’t be...

We thought we'd try this new pizza place on Rte 1, Scarborough. Phoned in an order for 2 small, 1 large pizza, salad, and fries. Got there to pick up, and they had no order for me. I was humiliated by the staff in front of other customers. Questions like "Did I call the right store?" "Did I order online?" "What did I order?" After several phone calls later, they admitted they gave my order to someone else. So they managed to create 2 unhappy customers. Unfortunately, I can't give a review for their food. There are 3 other pizza places within a mile of this one. They need to do better. I would suggest to the store that they need to admit their mistakes instead of trying to make it look like the customer screwed up. For other customers, I suggest you check your order...