Muller's Creamery — Restaurant in Toms River

Such a lovely place! The owners and staff are so personable and they make time to chat with everyone who comes through the doors in a genuine way. You can feel that they actually appreciate your business. They also happen to have the actual best ice cream I’ve ever tasted. It’s homemade and made from scratch and you can taste the difference. My 16 month daughter and I have been coming since they opened and they always welcome us so warmly and genuinely. My family loves coming here and we almost always end up staying for a quick life chat with the staff and owners. I highly recommend this place to anyone local or passing through the general area. They also roll out a cart into the street for when they close down the streets for town events on the weekend! Go support this awesome business and incredible...

Fantastic place! This creamery offers a superior ice cream experience! 🍦 Key advantages include its convenient downtown Toms River location with ample public parking (including a nearby parking garage at the Ocean County Library) 🅿️, excellent customer service—very knowledgeable, kind, and courteous—highlighting their commitment to premium ingredients and processes 🌟, and a great variety of flavors, including the Honey Lavender Custard and Pistachio that just became my favorites! 🔝 Their menu also features shakes, sundaes, to-go pints, cakes, vegan options, and more. Overall, it's an ideal destination for high-quality ice cream in Toms River. ✅ Oh, I almost forgot, they also have merchandise—sweatshirts and t-shirts. 👕 #IceCream #TomsRiver #Creamery #Dessert #Treat...

Heard good things about this place so I came in great expectations. Let’s start off with the parking. Yikes. After finding a parking spot I couldn’t easily figure out where this place was. Apparently it’s in like a co op type building with multiple businesses. Once I finally found it I was very impressed with the cleanliness of the store. Very stream lined. That’s the good. The bad, the ice cream. It was icy. I tried a few different flavors and again all icy / chalky consistency. I didn’t even finish it. Went in the garbage. For the price they are charging oof. There’s faaar better in the area. Side note. No soft ice cream? What? Sorry I don’t see what the people who are giving good reviews are eating. Maybe they haven’t had good ice...