Shuga Pie Shop — Restaurant in Town of Babylon

OMG!! Are used desserts are in a category which I call Ridiculous!! These deserts are so good, You could probably get addicted to them. I am a huge peanut butter and chocolate fan so that’s what I get every time they go there. But one time I was going there to bring dessert for a party I was going to, so I bought different kinds and flavors. Of course you want course you wanna make everybody happy when you’re a guest and you are bringing some thing. So I got the peanut butter with the chocolate, I got one that was cookies and cream, I got one that was death by chocolate, during Christmas time they had one that had crushed up candy cane in it they gave it a mint flavor as well. And the list goes on and on with the amount of flavors that they have. Right over there in the heart of Babylon Village on Deer Park Ave. in between the alleyway of fitness incentive and swell taco. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. Just make sure you got some either cold milk or cold almond or oat milk to go with it. And the coffee too of...

Shuga Pie shop is a must-stop if you are in the area. Their cakes have a very home-made feel to them, which brings home so much nostalgia to a Pennsylvanian who grew up with Amish whoopie pies around the home, and they have so many flavors, the most difficult thing you will experience in the day is choosing which ones to consume.

Maybe order a bunch and bring them to a potluck or family function, so you can chop them up + share and try many flavors.

My only disappointment is that they are not more accessible to us in Manhattan, but we heard rumor that they will be putting up a website soon that will allow for purchases and shipping of their delicious delights all over the country! Get excited!

And a bonus - this business is run by very nice people who are passionate about their creations! They work so hard to ensure the customer will be happy and are glad to spend time telling you about the area and recommending other local haunts to check out. Thanks for being such...

I've been going here since I moved to Long Island about 2.5 years ago and they were at the other shop, but never wrote a review. Their shuga pies are so good that everybody in the family is obsessed, vegan or not. It all started when my sister got me a phenomenal chocolate crumb cake from their former storefront for my birthday a few years back and I was amazed. The pistachio shuga pie is my favorite, but the flavors are creative and always delicious. Their service is exceptional, friendly and warm, and I wish them nothing but continued success.

We're already planning to buy a boatload of shuga pies for when we move away so we can have some stashed in the freezer, that's how...