Absolutely blown away! As a devoted foodie who’s always on the hunt for the next unforgettable bite, I can confidently say that The Bodega 524 Sandwich Shop in Clayton, NY is a game changer.
From the moment I walked in, the vibe was warm, welcoming, and buzzing with the energy of people who know they’ve stumbled onto something special. But let’s talk about the food — WOW. Every sandwich is a masterpiece — perfectly balanced, flavor-packed, and clearly made with care and top-tier ingredients. To say im impressed is an understatement..The bread? Dreamy. The meats and cheeses? Melt-in-your-mouth perfection. The sauces and toppings? Next level.
I tried the Pastrami on pumpernikle and I’m still thinking about it. You can tell this place is run by people who love what they do — it’s in every bite. AMAZING!!
If you’re anywhere near the Thousand Islands region, this spot is an absolute must. I’d give 10 stars if I could. Trust me, this isn’t just a sandwich shop — it’s a full-blown...
Read moreI seem to be the outlier here... Everyone raves about this place. Well I'm from Brooklyn and I never had a pastrami sandwich as cold and tasteless as the one I ordered there. Lot of meat but I could have went to the grocery store and bought a pound pastrami. I'm just used to real pastrami cooked locally, hot and fat and greasy and tasty. This was kind of bologna type pastrami. My wife ordered a Reuben and basically the same response... It wasn't hot at all, a Reuben that's not hot and buttery and juicy, loaded with sauerkraut and cheesy, to me. That's not a real Reuben type but and again, what do I know. The people there were nice but it would be hard for me to recommend to go there. Sorry because we need as many restaurants in...
Read moreOn vacation in June, my husband and I visited Bodega 524 and were so impressed with the sandwiches! He had the Muffaletta and I ordered the Rat Pack (created my own) which was sour dough, roast beef, pastrami, provolone, spinach, olive salad and Italian spice blend. These sandwiches were delicious and so huge we could eat only half. Also, we tried the Italian sushi which was flavorful. The staff are just so friendly and we loved the atmosphere! Prices are very reasonable for the amount that you get. We...
Read more