Amore's Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Goshen

I went to Amore's Pizzeria for the first time, April 2023. I will say that it was purely to try their pizza. So I ordered a pie to go. While I waited I looked around a little bit. The restaurant is a little on the small side. I would guess about six tables. Maybe more, but not many, if there are indeed more tables. They had a television for folks who may want to watch with their meal. The restaurant seemed sufficiently clean and organized. The two people working when I was there were friendly. I suspect they might have been the owners. The price for the large pizza was not cheap. But to be fair to Amore's, no place is cheap any more. With the much higher costs of the ingredients, the price is probably fair. I can say they were a little less expensive than the restaurant I use near my home. So they are pretty good there. The pizza was ready in approximately the time as promised. I left with the pizza and we ate very close by. Three of us sampled the pizza. Two of thought it was very good. One thought it was good, but stressed that they have had much better. But to be fair, much worse as well. And did say it was good and would order from them again. I can't comment on other food offerings or table service, as I didn't sample them. But what I did experience with Amore's, was a decent little restaurant with...

Best google search ever!

After an exciting day at Lego Land and being out-of-towners with a child who has food allergies, the quest for an allergy-friendly restaurant was on. We turned to Google and found a true gem: Amore’s Pizzeria.

Upon arrival, we were a bit skeptical due to its unassuming exterior. However, our doubts vanished the moment we walked in. We were welcomed like family, and the staff was incredibly attentive to our extensive list of allergies (egg, dairy, and tree nuts).

The young lady at the front took the time to consult with the owner, Brian, to ensure everything would be safe for our son. The result? Delicious wings and an allergy-friendly pizza that our son declared as the “BEST pizza he’s ever had in his life.”

Amore’s Pizzeria didn’t just serve us a meal; they provided a memorable experience filled with warmth and exceptional food. Brian, your dedication and hospitality were truly appreciated. We are seriously considering moving to New York just for Amore’s!

We will definitely be back, and we’ll be sending fellow Lego Land visitors your way. Cheers to...

I wish I could give 6 stars for Service - After making the mistake of ordering food at LegoLand I decided to leave the family at the hotel while I tried to find edible food for the three of us. I stumbled across this place and was absolutely floored by the generosity of the staff. Instead of making me buy individual slices, they let me take a whole pizza that was intended for slices at regular price. I wish I could explain the difference in quality between their food and the stuff available at LegoLand, but trust me when I say - this is great pizza at a fantastic price. The garlic knots, Neapolitan pizza, and old-school Sicilian pizza are delicious, nearly worth the 900mi drive to Goshen on their own! No joke - when I got into the elevator to head to our room at Legoland, another guest smelled the delicious aromas of the fresh pizza and garlic knots and said "Man I wish I'd have done that instead of going to the bricks family restaurant." If you're staying at LegoLand and want a Pizza or three, give these...