Brooklyn Square Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Hempstead

Ordered a Sicilian upside down for pickup. Visions of L&B Spumoni Gardens danced in my head as I looked forward to my first pie from this place. Parking was a breeze off the street in the adjacent lot next to the 7th Precinct. Walked in was greeted by a pleasant enough counter person. Place looked kinda clean, smelled pretty good. Grabbed my $28.- pie; which was quite weighty and I thought was reasonably priced, adjusted for inflation, and headed out to the lot. Drove home and opened the warm box at my kitchen table. What an ultimate let down when I opened it up. The box contents reeked of Parmesan dumped atop a seeming gallon of acrid sauce drowning a mere and slight hint of barely there mozzarella, all framed by a dark brown border of over cooked crust. Not so bad, you might say? When I went go grab a slice it flopped over lifelessly as the sauce and parm dust flowed off into the box. Still I remained undeterred and feeling adventurous, I took a bite. Horrible. Back into the box it went and after a shot trip to the garbage cans my brief but unforgettable experience with Brooklyn Square came to an unceremonious end. In summary, not the new favorite place we...

Awesome spot for the BEST Pizza!!

I’m a born & raised NY’er but I’ve been in Florida the past twenty years, where you just don’t get awesome pizza, bagels or anything bread related, down here!!

So being back in town for a visit, we were looking for an awesome NY pizza on our drive from Southampton into Jones Beach Theatre! A family member said he knew the perfect spot…

BROOKLYN SQUARE PIZZA!! They had many different styles of pies and they all look delicious but seeing as we were only stopping by once… We opted to get a regular/traditional NY pizza!

And it was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Totally hit the spot and wish I had this place near us! It’s a great place that has reasonable prices, delicious food and...

Brooklyn square pizza is a rare find. They make a type of pizza we know as "bakery pizza" which we have rarely found outside of Brooklyn. It is awesome. Of course they make other styles which are also great. I had chicken cutlet parmesan which was also really really good. Generally I'm spoiled because my family ccp is pretty darn good. Their sauce is delicious, they use quality ingredients and do not skimp on portions at all. Their prices are very reasonable as well If you want a great pie or basic dinner and heros absolutely try them out Going there for dinner...