Amico's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Irondequoit

I've had Amico's all of 4 times now. Two of which were people bringing the pizza into work or a party, and we loved those pies.

Both those times were great. Since they don't deliver out to our part of West Irondequoit, we stopped here twice now on our own.

The first time we just did a normal pepperoni pie, and garlic parm wings. Very basic, and we didn't love it, didn't hate it. But it was different from when we had it before. (I will say neither my wife nor I liked the garlic parm sauce, mainly because it didn't stick, and was not very well coated making the wings just vaguely butter flavored.

We found that first pie was too thick, but it wasn't bad.

We just had it a second time Friday, and asked our friends how they ordered, and all said they had done thin crust. Well, that was the key. The thin crust was what we were used to there, and it was a great pie. Did regular Boss Sauce on the wings, so they were great.

Got chicken tenders for our daughter, and they were very thick and juicy as well. So, now that we got the order down, we highly recommend this place.

(Pic is of their regular crust,...

Very disappointed with last nights dinner. We ordered a large pizza, wings & chicken tenders. • pizza was GREASY! I like a little grease with my pizza but within seconds of putting it on the plate, it pooled SO fast & dripped with every bite. Also, each piece barely had any sauce. If you took 5 bites to finish one slice & 2 or more of those bites had sauce, you were lucky • wings were meh. The sauce was good but the wings just did not look & cook well. Not good quality meat • chicken tenders were pathetic. You get 5 dinky tenders in a large box & these tenders are a joke. Tenders are our sons favorite food & he didn’t want them & when he finally did, he was not impressed.

We’ve had Amicos before and it was better than this so we’ll chalk it up to a bad night but if we ever do try it again & it’s better, then I’ll...

This is my new go-to for pizza. While it looks a little dinky from the outside, the food is always delicious, hot, and plentiful for the cost. My only complaint is that the garlic can get a little bitter- but, lucky for me, they offer sauces with and without extra raw garlic. The wings are enormous- always tender. The medium Buffalo sauce is perfectly flavorful and pleasantly sadistic on the spice level. Our go-to order, thick crust pizza with red sauce, extra cheese, pepperoni, and black olives with a 30 piece wings (medium sauce, natch!) leaves us full and with leftovers to nom off for the rest of the week. And you can't beat the price for this combo! It ends up being cheaper than a comparable amount of food from other pizza places in the area.

Add in the staff is awesome, and it's such a great gem on the...