Baked in Color — Restaurant in Town of Mamaroneck

I’m always seeing ads for baked in color on Instagram and I was finally in the area yesterday so we stopped in! It was definitely a lot smaller than I expected. They have cute rainbow decor throughout the store. They have a small variety of cookies and it seems to be just the same base cookie with a ton of coloring and different ‘mix-in’s’ mostly just the top. The flavors are: rainbow chocolate chip, unicorn s’mores, pink funfetti, and blue cookies n cream. Each cookie is $3 or you can get 4/$10. I chose the 4/$10 so I could try them all and the unicorn s’mores was definitely my favorite. The cookie is just okay for me. The Oreo and bits of chocolate on the top were what set it apart from the others for me. I also tried a giant brookie. I’m honestly not sure which flavor she gave me, but it was a st patrick’s day green (I’m guessing the blue cookies n cream but in green). It was so good! I loved the brownie/Oreo/cookie mix and it was definitely my favorite thing I tried. We also grabbed cake donut with sprinkles all over it. I didn’t love it because it was all melted by the time we got it home and it was just a mess. It could be partially because I’d the packaging? Honestly the packaging was a bit much for me. I don’t have a great suggestion for what they could do to fix it but it just felt very wasteful to me. The lady we talked to was super nice and mentioned they do bigger cakes as well. I’d definitely consider the brookie cake in the future. Overall a good experience!

Oh! They are...

If I could give no stars I would. Do not ever host a birthday party here. The nastiest staff in the world. “Jules” was the teacher and she not only was nasty to the parents there, to the point no one wanted to drop off at this party and ended up staying, but the nastiness towards children - especially mine. Telling excited children to “be quiet” “you need to shush” and grabbing their shoulders, singling out one child to “not call out” while everyone is calling out, and in the tone used that scared children, should not be par for the course for any party, but especially for a party in which the children were all doing exactly what they should, they were just excited. If this is how they run the birthdays they advertise, they should not be in business. Not only would I not recommend anyone waste their time or money in this establishment, but this will be a red flag location for me to tell everyone I know our experience and how to completely steer...

The brookies are awesome. Chocolatey and smooth and full of Oreo cookie goodness. The cookies are the exact opposite.

The cookies look like they’re separated but they’re not. It is basically a ball of dough that is hard to separate.

They tasted bitter and like almond extract was used instead of vanilla. There was no sweetness so it tastes like a traditional chocolate chip cookie but with no white or brown sugar. Basically a dough ball of flour, egg, almond extract (not vanilla), baking soda, and some chocolate chips.

We only tried one of the bags of cookies so maybe that batch was bad and they forgot to use sugar and vanilla.

Either way the brookies are awesome and worth every penny, the cookies...