Pantano's Eatery — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

DO NOT EAT HERE!

A few coworkers and i ordered lunch on friday (Feb 28th) My first complaint would be that their prices are way to high for the qty/quality of food. Second is i ordered half lemonade and half iced tea - i rcvd a fruit punch! Third, the potato salad had no taste and i threw it away after one bite.Fourth, the hero sandwich was the smallest i’ve ever seen, if there were 4 slices of corned beef i’d be surprised! While eating, i didn’t notice anything wrong, that was around 12p. While heading home, at 5p, i started to not feel good. Stomach growling and dull long pains. Needless to say (without tmi) i was VIOLENTLY ILL!!!! from the time i got home through this morning (Sat feb 29th) it’s now 2 pm and i still don’t feel myself. I have never felt this way from eating out before. And i think it goes without saying that i will NEVER eat from there again and i will make sure neither does my entire office...

Another Update- Why so many fake reviews praising this tool! He either writes the reviews himself or he buys customers food to post a 5 star review. place is garbage! Gian Luca is a fraud!

update: I went back and still the same experience. Funny how I write a bad review and it is followed by a whole bunch of 5 star reviews. seems to be a pattern of trying to erase bad reviews. the owner is a tool. He also posts on the Facebook group Dine LI, pretending to be a customer, saying how wonderful the food and staff is. what a pathetic joke.

I used to love this place. Prices are way overpriced and the size for the portions are half of what they used to be. You pay a high price for a skimpy sandwich that is followed by an attitude because you question the price. Don't bother going here. there are plenty of other delis around that make a...

Have seen this place for years and the food selections always sounded so good, plus people seem to like it. Tried it today - picked up a few sandwiches. Was immediately put off by the unpersonable young guy working at the counter - wasn’t really paying attention and wound up forgetting two dressings I asked for on the side, despite telling me twice “he got it.” Then asked for two medium cups with ice for my drinks & he tried to give me a mini paper coffee cup. OK. Ordered a panini and it wasn’t even pressed. So basically, it’s just a regular sandwich. The food was average, there are other local sandwich places that do a better job with more personable/attentive staff and lower prices (I got 2 sandwiches, 2 chips and 2 drinks and it was...