HTML SitemapExplore

Buttermilk Bake Shop — Restaurant in Virginia

Name
Buttermilk Bake Shop
Description
Nearby attractions
Centre Hill Mansion House Museum
1 Centre Hill Ave, Petersburg, VA 23803
Historic Old Towne Petersburg
413 N Sycamore St, Petersburg, VA 23803
The Exchange Building and Petersburg Visitors Center
15 W Bank St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Appomattox Event Center
9 W Old St #100, Petersburg, VA 23803
Petersburg Area Art League
7 E Old St, Petersburg, VA 23803, United States
Pocahontas Oldest Black Community in the United States
151 Pocahontas St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Walton Gallery Inc.
17 N Sycamore St, Petersburg, VA 23803, United States
arteXchange
20 W Old St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Nearby restaurants
Saucy's Sit-Down Bar.B.Q.
257 E Bank St suite c, Petersburg, VA 23803, United States
Croaker's Spot Petersburg
9 E Old St, Petersburg, VA 23803, United States
Wabi-Sabi
29 Bollingbrook St, Petersburg, VA 23803
The Brickhouse Run
407-409 Cockade Alley, Petersburg, VA 23803
Dixie Restaurant
250 N Sycamore St, Petersburg, VA 23803, United States
Old Towne's Alibi
305 N Sycamore St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Longstreet's Deli
302 N Sycamore St, Petersburg, VA 23803, United States
Andrade's International Restaurant
7 Bollingbrook St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Griffin Lounge
108 E Washington St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Tramonto Ristorante
322 N Sycamore St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Nearby hotels
Motel 6 Petersburg, VA - Fort Lee
25 N Little Church St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Hotel Petersburg, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
20 W Tabb St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Ragland Mansion LLC
205 S Sycamore St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Star Motel
39 S Crater Rd, Petersburg, VA 23803
Strawberry Hill - Inn & Event Venue
235 Hinton St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Best Inn
555 E Wythe St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Royal Inn
23 S Little Church St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Hotel Petersburg VA I-95 & E Washington St
25 S Crater Rd, Petersburg, VA 23803
King Motel
602 E Wythe St, Petersburg, VA 23803
Related posts
Keywords
Buttermilk Bake Shop tourism.Buttermilk Bake Shop hotels.Buttermilk Bake Shop bed and breakfast. flights to Buttermilk Bake Shop.Buttermilk Bake Shop attractions.Buttermilk Bake Shop restaurants.Buttermilk Bake Shop travel.Buttermilk Bake Shop travel guide.Buttermilk Bake Shop travel blog.Buttermilk Bake Shop pictures.Buttermilk Bake Shop photos.Buttermilk Bake Shop travel tips.Buttermilk Bake Shop maps.Buttermilk Bake Shop things to do.
Buttermilk Bake Shop things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Buttermilk Bake Shop
United StatesVirginiaButtermilk Bake Shop

Basic Info

Buttermilk Bake Shop

257 E Bank St, Petersburg, VA 23803
4.7(492)
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

attractions: Centre Hill Mansion House Museum, Historic Old Towne Petersburg, The Exchange Building and Petersburg Visitors Center, Appomattox Event Center, Petersburg Area Art League, Pocahontas Oldest Black Community in the United States, Walton Gallery Inc., arteXchange, restaurants: Saucy's Sit-Down Bar.B.Q., Croaker's Spot Petersburg, Wabi-Sabi, The Brickhouse Run, Dixie Restaurant, Old Towne's Alibi, Longstreet's Deli, Andrade's International Restaurant, Griffin Lounge, Tramonto Ristorante
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(804) 242-0027
Website
buttermilkbakeshopva.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Virginia
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Virginia
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Virginia
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
Pumpkin
(Vegan option available)
Sweet Potato
(Vegan option available)
Pecan
(Vegan option available)
Chocolate Pecan
(Vegan option available)
Apple Streusel
(Vegan option available)

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Buttermilk Bake Shop

Centre Hill Mansion House Museum

Historic Old Towne Petersburg

The Exchange Building and Petersburg Visitors Center

Appomattox Event Center

Petersburg Area Art League

Pocahontas Oldest Black Community in the United States

Walton Gallery Inc.

arteXchange

Centre Hill Mansion House Museum

Centre Hill Mansion House Museum

4.5

(67)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Historic Old Towne Petersburg

Historic Old Towne Petersburg

4.5

(173)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
The Exchange Building and Petersburg Visitors Center

The Exchange Building and Petersburg Visitors Center

4.2

(35)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Appomattox Event Center

Appomattox Event Center

4.8

(42)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Things to do nearby

French Language MeetUp
French Language MeetUp
Tue, Dec 30 • 6:00 PM
412 North Sycamore Street, Petersburg, VA 23803
View details
Brodnax Music Ent  Presents WEBBIE Live in concert @ The Civic Center
Brodnax Music Ent Presents WEBBIE Live in concert @ The Civic Center
Sat, Jan 3 • 10:00 PM
136 River Street, Petersburg, VA 23803
View details
Equine Wellness Camp
Equine Wellness Camp
Tue, Dec 30 • 9:00 AM
3000 Winnie Drive, South Chesterfield, VA, 3000 South St, Colonial Heights, VA 23831-7428, United States
View details

Nearby restaurants of Buttermilk Bake Shop

Saucy's Sit-Down Bar.B.Q.

Croaker's Spot Petersburg

Wabi-Sabi

The Brickhouse Run

Dixie Restaurant

Old Towne's Alibi

Longstreet's Deli

Andrade's International Restaurant

Griffin Lounge

Tramonto Ristorante

Saucy's Sit-Down Bar.B.Q.

Saucy's Sit-Down Bar.B.Q.

4.5

(782)

$

Click for details
Croaker's Spot Petersburg

Croaker's Spot Petersburg

4.3

(1.7K)

$$

Click for details
Wabi-Sabi

Wabi-Sabi

4.1

(718)

$$

Closed
Click for details
The Brickhouse Run

The Brickhouse Run

4.7

(459)

$$

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.

Posts

Kristena MitchellKristena Mitchell
We went this morning for doughnuts and they were phenomenal! They were everything I was hoping for. I’m surprised there is not a line out the door. They were moist and fresh and sweet, with a good bit of variety to be interesting but not so much that it was overwhelming. Pictured: lemon blueberry, chocolate sprinkle, Guinness, strawberry fruity pebble, Boston crème, and a HUGE Apple fritter. I do not have a favorite doughnut, but the lemon blueberry was unexpectedly stand out. They are priced well - $1.50/each for most doughnuts and a tiny bit more for the filled and fritter. The shop also sells cupcakes, cake slices, whole cakes, and cookies, but we did not indulge (this time!)
Tonya RossTonya Ross
Where oh where do I begin🧐… My first introduction to the marvelous bakery was the perky & infectious smile coming from behind the counter😝. Everything was soo clean and it smelled like BUTTER😍. All of the glasses were glistening , as though they were just cleaned moments before I arrived 🤩🤩. I was overwhelmed with all the treats & goodies. My sis had given me a list😁😁— I selected an apple fritter (which was the size of your head 😳), a delectable cream cheese cinnamon bun, maple bourbon cinnamon bun, red velvet cupcakes and they even had dog treats! Needless to say, everyone in the house was satisfied!!!! This bake shop is ahhhhhmazing.
Susan AndrewsSusan Andrews
Buttermilk Bake Shop is a wonderful place to go to enjoy yummy donuts, cookies, cupcakes, and cakes. Recently they took care of my daughter and son-in-law's wedding. We had blueberry, lemon and glazed donuts; we also had gluten free cupcakes and a small 6" wedding cake. They did an outstanding job. Everything was delivered on time, the food was fantastic and very yummy. The donuts were so light and tasty where it almost melted in my mouth. As you can see in the picture of cutting the cake, several donuts had already disappeared. Thank you to Laura and the team for doing a great job!
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Virginia

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

We went this morning for doughnuts and they were phenomenal! They were everything I was hoping for. I’m surprised there is not a line out the door. They were moist and fresh and sweet, with a good bit of variety to be interesting but not so much that it was overwhelming. Pictured: lemon blueberry, chocolate sprinkle, Guinness, strawberry fruity pebble, Boston crème, and a HUGE Apple fritter. I do not have a favorite doughnut, but the lemon blueberry was unexpectedly stand out. They are priced well - $1.50/each for most doughnuts and a tiny bit more for the filled and fritter. The shop also sells cupcakes, cake slices, whole cakes, and cookies, but we did not indulge (this time!)
Kristena Mitchell

Kristena Mitchell

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Virginia

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Where oh where do I begin🧐… My first introduction to the marvelous bakery was the perky & infectious smile coming from behind the counter😝. Everything was soo clean and it smelled like BUTTER😍. All of the glasses were glistening , as though they were just cleaned moments before I arrived 🤩🤩. I was overwhelmed with all the treats & goodies. My sis had given me a list😁😁— I selected an apple fritter (which was the size of your head 😳), a delectable cream cheese cinnamon bun, maple bourbon cinnamon bun, red velvet cupcakes and they even had dog treats! Needless to say, everyone in the house was satisfied!!!! This bake shop is ahhhhhmazing.
Tonya Ross

Tonya Ross

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Virginia

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Buttermilk Bake Shop is a wonderful place to go to enjoy yummy donuts, cookies, cupcakes, and cakes. Recently they took care of my daughter and son-in-law's wedding. We had blueberry, lemon and glazed donuts; we also had gluten free cupcakes and a small 6" wedding cake. They did an outstanding job. Everything was delivered on time, the food was fantastic and very yummy. The donuts were so light and tasty where it almost melted in my mouth. As you can see in the picture of cutting the cake, several donuts had already disappeared. Thank you to Laura and the team for doing a great job!
Susan Andrews

Susan Andrews

See more posts
See more posts

Reviews of Buttermilk Bake Shop

4.7
(492)
avatar
3.0
6y

Cute place, donuts were donuts. I would have given more stars if the staff was more friendly. Nobody said hi when we walked in or when we got to the counter. The guy finally said, "what can I get for you" after about a minute of us standing in front of him at the counter. The lady who checked us out wasn't anymore friendly. When she came out she also didn't say hi & just went right into, "have you been helped? What can I get you?" A smile and a hello to start would be great!

Their donuts are stacked up way high so you can't really see what they offer. You have to be able to read or know what the ingredients are - definitely not something my 4 year old can do. Even with a chair she was only able to see the bottom 2 rows of 4 of the donuts.

They did offer lots of baked goods including some vegan options. Unfortunately all of the vegan options have soy in them :( Aquafaba!!! Or other egg replacements is so much better and non carcinogenic! Anyways, we spent waaay more than anticipated $26 for a dozen donuts + a cinnamon roll & 2 specialty donuts that don't taste much different than the cheap Asian donut shop that you can spend about $10 less for the same thing.

If they were more friendly we would consider making it a special treat from time to time even with the cost, but you really just can't get past feeling like a number to people with no customer...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
2y

On 9/5/23, I ordered a dozen and a half gluten free cupcakes for a co-worker's birthday with Jazz (name she gave) over the phone, asked for the final cost and was quoted a price of $36.00. On the day of pickup (9/7/23) I was quoted the price of $54.54, told the lady I only had $40.00 and was not told of an additional cost for gluten free cup- cakes when I placed the order. Adding insult to injury, I was never offered an apology for the misinformation nor was I offered the price I was originally quoted, which would have been the correct thing to do. Instead the lady, with the short blondish colored hair and dark glasses behind the counter, never got her name unfortunately, that waited on me gave a look like do you want them or not and even after I said she should have told me when I placed the order of the additional cost, I still got the look like do you want them or not...had it not been for my co-worker's birthday, I would have left the dozen and a half gluten free cup cakes right there. Customer Service didn't exist on this day and management was unapologetic for their staff's error...I was recommended to this place because of the gluten free cupcakes unfortunately, I will not be returning nor recommending anyone else to...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
1y

I visited this bake shop this morning to purchase a cake for my husband, and unfortunately, my experience was less than satisfactory. I entered the shop with my service dog, and I was looking at their cake selection. The cakes look great, so I was trying to take a minute to choose. Then one of the staff members informed me that no dogs were allowed inside. I explained that my dog is a service animal, but she still insisted on taking my order outside. So I stepped out.

I went on my phone to look at the photos on Google Maps since I was not allowed to look inside. While outside, I saw there’s a sign that clearly stated service animals were allowed, but still I was made to feel uncomfortable and unwelcome. I tried to show the staff my service dog ID and tried to explain that I just needed to quickly choose a cake, but I was dismissed. While one of the staff members was polite and took my order, the other was rude and seemed to ignore my explanation.

It's disappointing to see this kind of treatment, especially when there's a clear policy in place. I was literally going to be in and out, it’s not like I’m staying. I hope they can improve their customer service. A simple acknowledgment and a bit of understanding would have made all...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next