Supreme Pizza — Restaurant in Waterford

They advertise on a BIG SIGN, 'Pizza By The Slice', I went in for the first time and found out the following:

Price per slice as of March 2025 is $3.76 (after tax), I was given $1.25 back from my $5.00 bill...they let me keep a penny back.

It took nearly five minutes for my one slice of cheese pizza to be ready for me to take. Upon opening the one slice pizza box, i was greeting by a moat of grease, took a couple napkins to soak some of it away. The slice was on the limp/small side at that.

It is difficult at best to taste what the pizza tastes like without that ooze of grease.

Their seats are wooden chairs only, approx 5 tables.

If you like very, very greasy pizza, this is for you. If you advertise 'Pizza By the Slice' , be prepared to serve that slice within a resonable time.

This was the actual reply from Supreme Pizza on 3/27/25:

"Response from the owner an hour ago Clearly your intent was to give a negative review from the start. I remember taking your order at the register and you seemed on edge. The pizza is not greasy and waiting a few minutes for a slice of pizza is not unreasonable. "

In response: I walked in during lunch time at approx 11:30 am; my intent was to have lunch. You call out a customer by calling them names + make paranoid claims against me. Please see the dissension this place takes...

Usually I’m satisfied with Supreme but this time was just ridiculous. I don’t even usually post reviews but I just wanted to let everyone know how rude the owner was. I called and ordered a slice and I literally heard the employee ask someone if they were doing slices and they said yes. I guess there must have been something wrong with the slice so the owner said “I don’t want anyone in here that’s ordering slices.” Then he kept trying to tell the other owner different excuses to give me as to why the slice was messed up. All while he was in the back and thought we couldn’t hear but the whole store heard. Just so he could stop wasting his breathe I said he knows we can hear him right. It was very rude and unprofessional and it’s not my fault that the employees weren’t communicating correctly. I’m not sure if I even want to come back because I always enjoy buying pizzas from here but when I decide to get a slice it’s not good enough, you would think business is appreciated but apparently not. This review is not because of the quality of the food, it’s because of the poor...

We love the food and travel from 2 towns over for take out. The owners and staff are friendly and do a great job. The restaraunt is always busy but the wait is always short.

A side note: The darkside of google reivews ala "Rachel and James Smith". Troll accounts used to unfairly slander a business. "Ms. Smith", a 300# karen type, was last seen having her payment repeately declined, causing a huge delay for the other customers waiting. After several declines the owner moved on to the other waiting customers - causing "Karen" to have a major entitled white girl meltdown, screaming profanities at the waiting customers. Apparently she isn't done and is now atttempting to damage a beloved neighborhood business, through no fault of their own.

Supreme Pizza has a 5 star rating for good reason - give them a try, you won't be...