OddFellows Ice Cream Co. — Restaurant in Wesley Chapel

Arrr, gather ‘round me hearties and lend an ear, for I’ve just dropped anchor at a most wondrous port o’ frozen treasure — Oddfellows Ice Cream Co. in Wesley Chapel, and by the beard o’ Poseidon, it be a place fit for kings, sailors, and sugar-cravin’ rogues alike! 🍨⚓️

The moment I crossed the threshold, I was greeted by a fair lass named Olivia, who handed me me loot — a mighty double scoop o’ Vanilla Bean so rich and creamy it near made me forget me own name. The flavor hit like a siren’s song on a calm sea — smooth, sweet, and speckled with vanilla bits finer than the sand on Tortuga’s shores. Aye, it were so good I nearly proposed to the cup.

The place itself be a feast for the eyes — red-and-white stripes like a captain’s finest flag, and walls lined with mirrors and cheeky monkey portraits starin’ back at ye as if to say, “Aye mate, ye’ve found the good stuff.” Even the cones stand at attention like proud little cannons, awaitin’ their turn to fire ice cream straight into yer soul. 🍦💥

They’ve got sodas too — fancy bottles of Boylan brew glintin’ like pirate gold under the counter light. And the smell! Sweet cream and sugar in the air, enough to make even a scurvy dog weep tears o’ joy.

If I were to give Oddfellows a grade, I’d say it deserves five outta five golden doubloons — and if I had more coins, I’d toss ‘em all their way! 🏴‍☠️

So if ye ever find yerself sailin’ through Wesley Chapel, steer yer ship straight toward Oddfellows. Tell ‘em Captain Peg Leg sent ye — and prepare to abandon all diets, ye who enter here.

Verdict: ☠️ Flavor: Deadly good ☠️ Atmosphere: Whimsical as a mermaid’s dream ☠️ Price: Worth every shiny piece o’ eight

Now hoist yer spoon, mates, and dig in — for the only crime here is leavin’ before tryin’ a...

Odd Fellows just opened yesterday, Friday, Oct. 3, 2025. I was already a fan from their Hyde Park Village Tampa location.

They can be found by the restaurants at Wiregrass Mall. Specifically next to The Living Room and Tmobile and across from Azteca. The area in the middle is currently on construction.

The Grand Opening was fun with a balloon maker present. He also did card tricks and magic show tricks. They did the ribbon cutting ceremony and everyone stood in line for their ice cream. Everyone there was super friendly, welcoming, and helpful.

I had the mango sticky rice ice cream and exotic fruit sorbet. They were def what I love, tropical. They also have Ube and Pandan coconut which are unique for the area.

Excited for them bc they are the only ice cream in the wiregrass mall area. Check them out!

They have inside and outside seating and they have a vibrant circus theme even with a cute little...

i’ve been waiting for the opening of this ice cream shop for a little bit ! the atmosphere is super fun and quirky which i love, the variety of different flavors is so nice, and as someone who has lactose intolerance it’s hard to find a good shop with dairy free options that still has the creamy texture and taste of regular dairy ice cream. the owner was super sweet ! will be coming and may even be a...