Naty's Pizza #2 — Restaurant in West Chicago Township

Pretty good tavern-style pizza. There are other good pizza places around here but let's be honest, you want good version of different TYPES of pizza. When I want that classic Chicago tavern pizza rather than a New York or Sicilian or deep dish, this is a good place to order from in West Town. Prices are reasonable. I ordered delivery and it showed up on time and was warm. I would order again.

I got a thin pepperoni, which was not too cracker thin like some places do. I like when the pizza isn't like a cracker, it seems to be a little more substantial and thus a better value. Got fried mozz sticks were your typical (presumably non-store-made) appetizer but not too expensive.

Five stars because it's just what I expect from a tavern pizza and it seems to be the best of the type in the area (as far as I can tell). Meaning, for this type of pizza, this is (so...

We’ve been loyal customers of Natys Pizza for over 18 years, but after what happened this past Friday night, we will never be ordering from them again.

We ordered a pizza as we’ve done countless times before. My father grabbed a slice and immediately bit into a cooked-in chicken wing bone — yes, a full, bald chicken wing bone embedded inside the pizza. He nearly broke a tooth!

I called right away to let them know, and instead of concern or accountability, the owner gaslit me by saying it was “absolutely impossible.” As a business owner myself, I would’ve at least offered a refund — but all he offered was another pizza. That response was not only dismissive but incredibly unprofessional.

After nearly two decades of support, this experience was both shocking and disgusting. We’re deeply disappointed, and unfortunately, we won’t...

Tried to make order over phone and the dude had me on hold for 8mins and hunged up. Not busy at all, business was poor and they couldn't take an order. They told me it was going to cost $16 for a small 10' pizza and charged me $19 for it, which wasn't that great. Not worth the price in Chicago. All there reviews are from family and friends. I felt disrespected and cheated. If your from Chicago, I recommend you try to find something else because you won't like the...