Big Cheese Pizza — Restaurant in Willoughby

This is the best f* pizza I have had in a hot minute. The sauce is perfectly seasoned. Its not too greasy. The dough adds to the flavor. Usually I save some pizza for lunch the next day but not this time. WE FINISHED IT. I would have gotten 2- I would have tipped more had I known how heavenly this pizza was. This addicting perfection must have some crazy secret ingredient- magic? My large cheese pizza was ready in less than 15 minutes. The person behind the counter was nice. It was hot and ready when I got there. I'm very happy. Maybe I was just hungry but maybe its one of the best. Needless to say, I'm coming back soon...

Ordered pizza from here once, it was very bland!! I ended up putting my own seasoning on it. Decided to give it a second shot and stop in to get some slices of pepperoni, hard to mess this up. Before I made the trip over I did verify on there website what time they served slices till. It read daily till 6pm. Well when I got there I was told they weren't serving any. Inconsistency is a pet peeve of mine!!! Especially if you are advertising it. I imagine they did not have slices because they do not have enough business but this inconsistency has helped me make up my mind that I will never waste my...

I live out of town from Erie, PA, but am now in Ohio for a bit with my wife, we wanted to try a new pizza place and came across Big Cheese Pizza, we decided to try their signature pizza and it was actually really good, they also take note of instructions when you ask for light sauce, their Reese cookie was also very good, and the crust for the pizza tasted amazing as well, they have a really clean interior look and the customer service was great, I would recommend this to anyone looking for a new pizza place or if you’re just visiting, we will definitely be...