Commack Inn — Hotel in Town of Smithtown

To all who leave this place a review, scathing and upset about the owners or the conditions of the rooms and so on….. let me give you a reality check and an honest review first off. The Motel is used almost exclusively by escorts and extremely short stay individuals. so the mirrors in the room are meant for the view.. the cash deposit is there because when you’re dealing with such unsavory people, they are going to screw you every time and when you happen to be a nice normal guest this feels very obtuse. Third room service don’t expect any and don’t expect someone to come and fix your Jacuzzi at 12 o’clock at night… or in fact don’t expect the front as to do anything at pretty much any point in the day except 11 am check out, and yes, they will start bothering you a minimum of 10 minutes early. with all that said know where you are it’s Commack. It’s the Commack Inn all you have to do before you get a room at a motel is drive around it then park for a few minutes. You should be able to gauge what type of Motel, you are at within that timeframe, if you’re gonna be bothered by women of the night on savory people this is definitely not the place to go. Also don’t expect a five star comfort level in their bed pillows Jacuzzi or any other amenities it’s just reality don’t be so mad at the Indian guy he’s rude, he’s mean, wouldn’t you be if you owned a motel and had to deal with drug addicts and escort all day they’re not the nicest that’s why he don’t get on the phone...

First lets start with the positives: decenlty convenient location near the parkway and lots of places to eat/shop on Jericho Tpk.

Now the negatives: Service was abysmal even for a motel. The front desk woman was rude and short with me. They require a ridiculous $300 CASH ONLY deposit just to get a room, a big ask in this day in age, especially when your stay will likely be for much less money. Next the room. Was it clean? Kinda, but I didn't take a black light to it (please someone do this). The interior was extremely dated with a mirror on the cieling above the bed. I know what this hotel is often used for... but the reminder is not appreciated. Lighting was dim and gave a gross feeling to the whole room. Finally comfort... my biggest gripe. I have stayed in many motels in my life, and I will say the pillows are usually a non-issue (especially for one night). However the pillows I slept on at the Commack Motor Inn felt like malleable ROCKS (hard to describe). You can press into them but in the morning its like a boulder was under my head, uncomfortable to say the least. I was cranky when I woke up due the pillows and had to eat and drink coffee at the nearby IHOP to cure myself.

There are so many better motels (Whitman Lodge in Huntington Station, Norwich Inn in East Norwich, Chalet Inn in Centerport) with comparable and often better pricing. Save your time, money, and sleep, even if just for a one night stand, and...

DONT EVER STAY HERE EVER THE ROOMS ARE NOT WHAT THEY SHOW ON THE PICTURES AT ALL!!!! THEN WHATS ON THE WEBSITE THEY NEED TO CLOSE DOWN… THIS WAS THE WORSE HOTEL EVER THE ROOM WAS NASTY WASNT CLEAN AT ALL THE DOOR DIDNT LOCK AT ALL I STAYED UP ALL NIGHT BECAUSE I DIDNT FEEL SAFE AT ALL THE OWNER NEEDS TO BE ASHAMED FOR THE PRICE THEY ARE CHARGING FOR THIS MOTEL. I AM GOING TO MAKE SURE THAT EVERY SOCIAL MEDIA SITE KNOWS ABOUT THIS HOTEL THE SHOWER WATER WAS COLD BUT ONLY GOT HOT WHEN YOU SHUT THE COLD WATER OFF IN THE BATHROOM SINK. THEY HAD USED PRODUCTS ON THE BACK OF THE TOILET I HAD TO PUT A CHAIR AND THE IRON BOARD UP AGAINST THAT OTHER DOOR TO FEEL MORE SAFE ALL SOMEONE HAD TO DO WAS JUST KICKED THE DOOR AND IT WOULDVE OPEN THEY HAD PORN ON THE DAMN TV CHANNEL AS I AM FLIPPING THROUGH THE CHANNELS TO FIND A MOVIE THE BATTERIES IN THE REMOTE AAS DYING HAD TO KEEP HITTING THE BACK OF THE REMOTE TO FLIP THROUGH THE CHANNELS. THE BUTTONS ON THE PHONE WAS MISSING I CAN GO ON AND ON. IT WAS JUST HORRIBLE NEVER AGAIN. THE OWNER NEEDS TO SELL THIS HOTEL TO SOMEONE WHO CAN ACTUALLY REVAMP TUE WHOLE HOTEL AND SOMEONE WHO ACTUALLY CARES ABOUT GUESTS, THEY SAFETY SLEEPING CONDITIONS ROOM CONDITIONS. ESPECIALLY AFTER A LONG DRIVE TO NEW YORK MY REVIEW IS A 0 I WISH I COULD GO LOWER THAN THAT… DONT STAY HERE EVER!!!...