Monmouth Cards — Local services in Livingston

This place has got such a great atmosphere!! Im a 42 year old man just getting back into card collecting and i remember the old school card stores. It was some old dudes wondering why youre taking so long and hated when I asked too many questions 😆 good memories, but this place has younger staff and they gotta a great energy that show equally to everyone there. To the kid with his mom to my old self reliving fun times. They even help you open the cards and immediately put them into sleeves for you if you ask. Also will get just as excited with ya when you pull a good cards. You definitely forget your age when youre in there. ...

Nice space, good people but prices for singles are crazy. Guy originally quoted me about 160% of last comp on a card. Showed him the recent sales then told me the best he could do is match the last eBay sale. I politely passed. But as I was leaving I over heard another employee talking over the phone regarding purchasing cards from customers saying the buy at 60-65% of last comp. Really dosent make sense that they will make you pay 100% while they pay a huge discount for the same reason of fees and shipping in regards to eBay sales. Great place to grab boxes but would not go there to buy specific cards or sell...

Five Stars Isn’t Enough!

We had the pleasure of being helped by one of the most knowledgeable and personable employees (Tim) I've ever encountered at a trading card store. From the moment we walked in, they greeted me with genuine enthusiasm and made me feel like a valued customer—not just another person browsing.

Thank you Livingston Monmouth Trading Cards, we'll be back soon, it was a pleasure doing...