Nutmeg Bakeshop — Restaurant in Newmarket

The pastries are great, cookies etc however- ordering a cake from here is ridiculous. You can ONLY order what's on their "seasonal" menu which is only 4 options. Ordering a cake for a birthday party of 30 people you would think that they would give you a few more options or allow you to customize the flavour somewhat - I get that it's a busy time of year and they want to make it as simple as possible for themselves "quantity over quality" but I mean adding sprinkles to the vanilla batter for 1 cake i think is a pretty minor request - I even offered to pay more for the trouble..... my daughters favourite cake and unfortunately their disregard to make a simple cake a little altered to suit a customers request was turned down . That left a very sour taste in my mouth . It's unfortunate too because their cakes are very good and always my go to for family birthdays. Good for simple flavours and non custom requests as long as your ok with choosing from 4 flavours, if not go somewhere else. Not...

We walked by this cute shop & decided to go in for a sweet after lunch treat. This was less than an hour before they closed so there weren’t a ton of options but it was so hard to choose because everything looked amazing. The cinnamon bun, coffee cake, nutella pastry & earl grey scone looked to die for but we ended up going for the cookie butter scone, brown butter choco chip cookie & brown butter confetti cookie. They all exceeded expectations & it was $7.50 for everything which i feel is pretty reasonable for the quality and the size of the scone was huge. Nothing was overly sweet it was just perfect and tasted fresh & moist. We will be going back earlier in the day to try more variety. I wish there was somewhere to sit but it’s not...

The croissants are a must eat. You'll never find the same taste or texture anywhere else. You can tell they bake with so much love and passion, it just reflects in their baked goods. We tried their almond, almond chocolate, cheese and plain croissants. They're all super flaky and full of delicate flavours. We also tried their sourdough breads. I like them all especially the rye one! I tried looking for a good local bakery for a long time and didn't have much luck, but now have finally found one. This was my first time ordering from them, and we will be ordering for all occasions in the future. I hope they never go out of business due to the pandemic. The owners are wonderful folks! Please support...