McKayla Marie Sweets — Restaurant in Ashwaubenon

Is it bad that my child’s first words were “Macs” (Macarons) and “Coo-coos” (Cookies) because we visit McKayla Marie Sweets so often? Some say that’s bad parenting, I say my child is a genius for having such great taste at a young age. It’s such a joy visiting McKayla and Keegan, they greet you with a smile, and every baked good they sell is somehow better than the last one. We’ve been enjoying their treats for over a year now and I don’t think we will ever tire of how tasty they are! McKayla has done 3 cakes for us so far and they have always been delicious. The process of ordering the cakes was simple and SO easy to understand from the website, and if you have any questions it’s fun to stop in and bounce questions and ideas off McKayla. (Plus you have an excuse to buy a lil snack) The cream puffs EASILY beat the ones at the state fair, and don’t walk, RUN whenever she has tuxedo cake or death by chocolate cake in the case because holy moly they’re the most incredible desserts you will ever try. Don’t sleep on her S’Mores Cookies - They taste like childhood summers, so yummy and nostalgic! As someone who lives by the philosophy of “I always need a little treat.” MMS checks that box each and every...

Easy to order and select delectable treats off of the website. I missed entering the pick up date and the bakery reached out to me to clarify within minutes of my order for next day pick up. I took the cookies and macaroons to an educational function and they were the highlight of everyone’s day and taste buds. Everyone oohed and ahhed over the treat presentation and the fantastical first to last bites.

Thank you for your quick service and response. I’ll order more from here in the future for...

McKayla Marie Sweets did an incredible job with our wedding cutting cake! It was absolutely flawless. So stunning that we received endless compliments from our guests about how beautiful it was. And it tasted just as amazing as it looked! The team was professional, responsive, and such a pleasure to work with throughout the process. They made everything so easy, and the end result was perfect. We’re so grateful and highly recommend them to anyone looking for gorgeous (and delicious)...