Killer Crust Pizza Company — Restaurant in Athens-Clarke County Unified Government

This was, without a doubt, the most delicious pizza I have had in years. We will absolutely be back! We decided to try Killer Crust on a Saturday night, and every single part of the experience was fantastic. First, the food is on another level. We tried two different pizzas, and both were incredible. The Killer Supreme was loaded with fresh, high-quality toppings. We also got a Build-Your-Own pizza with a pesto base, fresh mozzarella, mushrooms, and spicy fried chicken, which was genuinely phenomenal. Even the crusts were perfect-we got to try both the original and the gluten-free cauliflower crust, and both were amazing. What really makes this place special, though, is the vibe. The music was fantastic, playing a great mix of classics that made the whole atmosphere feel welcoming and fun. The open kitchen design is a brilliant touch. It was so cool to be able to watch the staff so skillfully and delicately prepare the pizzas. Seeing them work with the dough was entertainment in itself and just shows how much care goes into the food. From the incredible food to the great music and the fun of the open kitchen, this was just a lovely, perfect experience. If you're looking for the best pizza in town, this is the spot. Highly,...

Normally I love Killer Crust....they are a go to on a Friday night for sure. But the past 2 times have broken my heart. Once they gave my pizza to someone else and left me sitting for more than 45 minutes. I got my money back and left with no pizza and no dinnner. Their solution was to offer to add stuff to another pizza that had been sitting there and give that to me. Last night, we got a pizza, the person taking the order (by phone) was awesome, as was the person who brought the pizza to the car (I am on a scooter and it is an ordeal to get that in and out of the car). The pizza was over cooked (veggies shriveled up to nothing), the pepperoni was too salty, leaving the pizza too salty when removed, the cheese was cooked away, and the crust hard as a rock. I have had many pizzas from here but the last two experiences have broken my heart. I love this place, and fear that the quality is dropping. Please get it together, I need...

i think this pizza is worse than mid. the entire pizza was so dry it was curving upwards. it was like a giant pizza crouton, but croutons are like 10x better. they took like 30 minutes to get 3 slices out, and they forgot the basil on a BASIL pizza 😭 idk if you want something local just go to little italy, mellow mushroom, or even papa john’s would be better.

service was great, though. they were super nice and everything was clean - even the bathroom.

overall the food was a 1/10 - everything was insanely bland and dry. the 1 point is given because the pizza with balsamic was interesting at least.

i have never given a negative review but i’m like offended (?) by how mid this pizza was. i wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone.

i also want to add i do like their branding. i wanted to come here because i thought...