Spice It Up — Restaurant in Beach Haven

This shop is a true hidden gem! Our uncle recommended it to us while we were visiting the brewery, and it blew our minds. Sandwiches were extremely fresh and full of flavor!! We enjoyed the “Original Dan” and the “Ship Bottom Brewery”. I cannot rave enough about the Bella Vidalia spread on the Original Dan, OUT OF THIS World!! Meats were of a very good quality (mom thought the pastrami was very lean, thinly sliced, and delicious), bread was super fresh (I believe a rosemary olive oil), proportions were excellent (we split them with some pretzels as an afternoon snack, but would definitely be filling for one). Shopkeepers were extremely welcoming, friendly, and knowledgeable. We will be back. Thank you...

Saw the reviews while down in the area and had to check it out. Easy to find , some parking right outside, but plenty around (this review is written in Feb good luck in the summer months). Owner was friendly and immediately derailed my choice by telling me about the specials which sounded awesome. I held strong and got The Original Dan sandwich. Got a chance to check out the awesome sauces and rubs around the shop, there's some great stuff here. Sandwich was fantastic and flavorful with plenty of pickles on the side, will definitely be back to try more of the menu. If you're headed to Ship Bottom Brewing grab a sandwich and have it at the brewery, its totally allowed....

We have come here for lunch every time while visiting LBI since Spice It Up first opened their doors, because they have THE best sandwiches on the island! My reviews would be ranked even higher if possible based just on the food, but the owner went even further when we accidentally ordered the wrong sandwich. He came out to check and see how we were enjoying the food and when he found out the one sandwich wasn’t what we wanted, he replaced it with the other one … and free of charge. It is so refreshing to see the care fit customers that goes along with absolutely amazing food! Cannot recommend this...