Mister Pizza — Restaurant in Buffalo

OK, tonight was kinda like the last straw I moved in the area. This is probably my third time ordering from the place now. I know that you stay open kinda late so you know people get tired and things like that which is understandable but when I place a order And I tell them specifically how I want it made it should come to me exactly how I want my food, seeing as how expensive the food is nowadays…. now today I order a calzone. I tell them I want everything crust Italian sausage well done onions, pepperonis (chard) , tomatoes. When it came, the presentation was fine yes, it was a little darker on the top, but I asked for it well done and I don’t mind it being a little dark now when I spoke to the guy on the phone, I asked where they gonna cook the onions with my Italian sausage the guy told me yeah I also asked for tomatoes thinking that he will put the tomatoes on the grill with the meat as well seeing as though it’s a calzone, he put sautéed onions and just straight, diced tomatoes on my calzone you would think a cook would have enough sense to know to not put the sautéed onions and raw tomatoes. Straight in the calzone because when you bake it, it’s going to present some type of moisture. The proper way would be to cook my meat, cook fresh onion with the meat, chopped them up add the tomatoes last my pepperoni should have been charred on the grill, which never happened!!!!!!. They sent me those straight out of the pack as well, which they’re gonna have to cook inside this dough and cheese and present moisture as well from the grease !!!!!!!! Thats specifically why I asked him to char my pepperonis it’s like it’s one thing to order something and not like it but come on for me to basically explain to you exactly how I want my food and it come a complete different way. It’s just insane. Oh, and might I add there was barely any ricotta cheese in my calzone now I’m sitting here at 2:20 AM $30 less picking through a soggy mess pissed and I honestly know how business is it’s probably not even the cooks fault it’s probably the person who answered the phone but come on guys I know the small things can be annoying at times, but those are the things that keep good...

We like to try different pizzerias when the occasion arises. I can say I was less than pleased with my first experience with Mister Pizza Elmwood. I was near the neighborhood and had heard they had some good pie. I ordered three slices online around 9:50 a.m. After paying and including a generous restaurant tip, I was given a pick up time of 10:20, perfect I thought. I was notified when my order was confirmed and in the process of being made. On the way to pick up my order, I was sent an email postponing my estimated pick up time to around 10:47. I thought, ok, they're the only pizza place open so early so they may be busy, but mind you, I was notified my order was in the process of being made. I arrived to pick up my order around 10:35, I was told "about 8 more minutes". Politely I said that's fine, thank you. 15 minutes later I was presented with my TWO slices. I said no, I ordered three slices. Being asked what they were, I responded accordingly. He went back inside starting at the receipt, came back or only to tell me that he was sorry, he missed the third slice, he only saw two on the order. He offered me two choices for replacement, one of which I had actually ordered, completely defeating the purpose of trying new variations of pizza. The other was the standard cheese and pepperoni. Being two hours after my initial order time, I accepted the cheese and pepperoni, also followed by his excuse that they had been busier than usual and had a large number of personal pizzas going out. So my three slices were obviously moved to the back burner, literally, in order to provide for a lie e lucrative order. I didn't appreciate the wait, the excuse, the botched order or his solution to said order. There was no reason I should be made to wait an extra 50 minutes for a wrong order because they are making more money with a different order. I didn't appreciate that AT ALL. The pizza itself....it's pizza. My customer satisfaction....I will not be a returning customer. Others may have had great, problem free orders, but mine was...

Okay, My order was for a large thin pizza with cheese, pepperoni, light onions, mushrooms, and sausage. A little too salty, otherwise very good!

I ordered a large pie, which I haven't done in a long time. The reasons why I wanted pizza "Specifically" from Mr. Pizza is simple! I not too long ago went to La Nova Pizzeria. How they stay in business serving up that slop, I have no idea! After eating what they call pizza, I told myself I am never eating that pizza again! I went there because they're close to where I live, and I was being lazy! On a scale of 1-10 I give La Nova's pizza about a 4.5. It's nothing great.

After eating that slop I was really craving a much better tasting pizza and told myself "I should have just went to Mr. Pizza!" Here's why Mr. Pizza makes a way better tasting pizza than La Nova.

1 Mr. Pizza's sauce taste's lively! La Nova's = flat. 2 Mr. Pizza I believe uses a better quality cheese. 3 Mr. Pizza's dough, this is important because I believe it separates a so so pizza into a way better tasting pizza. The dough from Mr. Pizza has a crunch to it! No, it's NOT burnt, it's just awesome! Not only that, but the dough also seems like there's a touch of sweetness to it. It's very subtle, but very good. Whoever came up with this recipe, knew what they were doing!

This is what makes Mr. Pizza like one of the best tasting pizzas EVER!

There are a lot of pizzerias out there, but Mr. Pizza's pizza is like Gourmet in comparison! La Nova's is a beautiful place, but their pizza is like eh! 4.0-4.5 on a scale of 1-10, It's nothing great.

Mr. Pizza's pizza on a scale of 1-10, I would give them a solid 8. So why even mention La Nova? Well if it weren't for that slop they sold me that they call pizza I would have never longed for such a greater tasting pizza such as Mr. Pizza's pizza!

Mr. Pizza's Pizza Is Simply Better! Like "WAY...