My Little Italy’s Pizza — Restaurant in Fredericksburg

We ordered from Little Italy in Fredericksburg, VA last night through Uber Eats. The delivery was prompt, which we appreciated, but unfortunately, that was the only positive aspect of our experience.

We ordered the spaghetti and meatballs, a Sicilian pizza with pepperoni, and an 8-count of mumbo wings. Upon opening the spaghetti, we were immediately hit with an overwhelming dirty dishrag smell, as if the noodles had been cooked in unclean water. It was so off-putting that I couldn’t bring myself to take a single bite.

Next, the Sicilian pizza was missing the pepperoni we specifically ordered. To make matters worse, the crust was tough and tasted like cardboard, while the overall flavor made it clear they had used the cheapest possible ingredients.

As for the mumbo wings, the sauce was nothing more than overly sweet ketchup, lacking any of the tangy, savory flavor you would expect.

This was our first time trying Little Italy, and it will certainly be our last. We were thoroughly disappointed with the poor quality, lack of attention to detail, and overall lackluster flavors. I don’t typically write reviews, but I felt compelled to share our experience and discourage others from wasting...

I've ordered from here well over 12 times on DoorDash—honestly, it's kind of embarrassing how often! The first four to Five times, the pizza was absolutely incredible—cooked to perfection, probably some of the best pizza I've ever had.

Unfortunately, things went downhill after that. I'm not sure if there was a change in staff or if the new cook wasn’t properly trained, but the quality dropped dramatically. The pizzas became almost inedible, which was really disappointing. I gave it a few more tries, hoping it was just a fluke, because I know how amazing your food can be—but sadly, the quality never bounced back.

At this point, I’ve decided I won’t be ordering from here again. I hope things improve in the future, because your early food was...

Decided to try this place for the first time and kinda let down. Ordered a medium margarita pizza and what arrived only tastes ok. The crust is rather bland and the decision to put what looks like black pepper on top is rather..... interesting. I also 100% could be mistaken but it looks like they use preformed, possibly frozen dough blanks, like youd find in the super market. Not once have i ever gotten a pizza delivered that was covered in all these perforations that look almost machine made. They're all uniformly spaced. The bottom is barely browned. It honestly feels like im eating a dressed up store bought pizza. Kinda expected better from a purported italian restaurant. It's not TERRIBLE, its kinda just..meh. I probably won't...