Red Key Tavern — Restaurant in Indianapolis

Red Key is one of those unassuming spots that has managed to carve out a loyal following despite being a “hole in the wall.” Tucked away from the hustle and bustle, it’s a place where strangers often end up as friends over a couple of cheap drinks. It’s been around for years, offering a nostalgic, no-frills vibe that draws in regulars and newcomers alike.

First off, the drinks are reasonably priced, a big plus in an age where many bars tend to overcharge. One thing to keep in mind, though, is that Red Key operates on a cash-only basis, which might be inconvenient for some. If you’re heading out here, make sure you’ve got cash in hand.

The bar itself is small, and while it may not offer the most luxurious experience, it’s packed with character. There’s both indoor and outdoor seating, making it a versatile spot depending on the weather, but parking can be a challenge. The lot is cramped, and there’s a tricky back lot situation where spaces get blocked, so you’ll want to make sure you park with care—not to mention, be mindful of the houses and garages in the area. No one likes a bad neighbor.

While the bar is great for a low-key night out, there are a few notable downsides. The jukebox has been broken for months, which means you won’t have music unless there’s live entertainment, which can be hit or miss. If you’re someone who enjoys a good playlist while sipping on your drink, this could be a dealbreaker.

Also, be aware that Red Key has a strict no-cursing policy. It’s an unusual rule for a dive bar, but it helps maintain a certain vibe. If you tend to let the occasional expletive slip, you might want to curb that before heading in.

The service is definitely a bit of a mixed bag. Some bartenders are friendly and welcoming, creating a warm atmosphere, while others can come off as less than enthusiastic. It’s a bit of a gamble in that regard, but when you hit it right, it feels like you’re visiting a long-lost friend.

All things considered, Red Key is a great spot if you’re looking for an unpretentious bar with a chill atmosphere. It’s not perfect, but that’s part of its charm. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, there’s something endearing about this little dive, as long as you’re prepared...

This is what you'd call a dive bar. Set your expectations low so you're not disappointed too much. If you're looking for beers and a good burger in a casual setting, then this might be a good place for you. It's not a good place to get cocktails -- selection is extremely limited to just the basics and the basics are nothing to write home about. Had some Manhattans and they were somewhat small portion in a Nick and Nora glass and we're just alright. Vodka martini was too much vermouth. That said, the burgers were really good. So beer and burger is probably the way to go here.

One important note: this is a cash only place, which really amps up the dive feel. Seriously, 2022. I'll pay the CC fee. Better than the ATM at the back of the place. So that throws red flags like they must be evading tax or something, which is a...

No hookah here so disregard anything regarding that. Just your quintessential local watering hole and dive. No frills and the absolute perfect ambiance and vibe. Cold beer, affordable drinks and food (freshly prepared), and efficient service. Whether popping in by yourself for one or catching up with a group of friends while not wanting to go to an overly crowded bar, this is the spot. The real treat is when you are lucky to catch live music as well. Cash only so come prepared or hit...