Sicilian Bakery Inc — Restaurant in Jefferson Township

Over the course of two visits here Meat Arancini 3.5/5. Nice and crispy outside with a soft and moist inside. But it was missing a little something to push it over the top. I had the meat one, but theres also a veggie one. These are of good quality though. Chocolate Donut 4.9/5. Highly enjoyable. Should have gotten two. Custard Danish 3.8/5. The very outer edge felt stale. But the inside was soft and flaky. I enjoyed this more at the end as I ate around the edge and left the filling for last. Service 5/5. The lady was super friendly and explained their sandwich and pizza menu to me. Atmosphere 4/5. Its small, but cozy. I saw a lady sitting near the window before I walked in, but never noted how many seats they had here. Selection 4.9/5. Only the one donut flavor. Which is a shame because it was good and I wonder how good other varieties might have been. They had pretty much everything a standard bakery should have. Prices 4.7/5. I thought everything was very reasonably priced, if not on the cheaper side. I've included photos of their menu. Overall, I would rate Sicilian Bakery at 4.4/5. Definitely two enjoyable visits. I will return to try their deli sandwiches...

I was really excited to try this place, I heard a lot of really good things. I called today to get a cake for husband, the lady on the phone was very nice. When I arrived, the woman at the front was very rude. I asked if she could write something on the cake bc they told me on the phone that they could. I had it very clearly written on a piece of paper “happy birthday to my otter half,” my husband loves otters. I just got home and opened the cake and it says “otter wife”. Common sense would tell you that doesn’t make sense and perhaps inquire before you wrote it on the cake. I honestly think the woman was rude to me bc she thought I was gay. Even if I was, that is not an excuse. It was clearly written on the paper I handed her. The cake was $40 and ruined. 0/10. Wildly disappointed. Waste of...

I have a lot to say about this bakery! I have reviewed a few different bakeries, and they all have their own style or a specialty that they’re known for. Sicilian bakery is right up there with the best of them. From the minute, you walk in the bakery, you’re greeted by the girls behind the counter, always so friendly. They have everything you can imagine in there from slices of their Italian bakery pizza Arancini’s / rice balls, Iris stuffed cannoli filling to their homemade Italian bread, outstanding! I actually remember the original bakery on grand Avenue in Chicago. they have been around a long time, right there tells you they are one of the best! Now the real question is, would I go back again? Of course, time...