Amici Italian Grill — Restaurant in Middletown

My daughter & myself walked in and looked at their menu for some time because there were so many yummy sounding dishes. We both chose dishes that required them to omit items as well as add items & they got our orders right the first time. I gotta say I just love their Tomato Cream Sauce that they make for pasta. You can get it in certain dishes. They also have make your own pasta & best of all you can get a side container of the Tomato Cream Sauce for only $4.00. I did & it was totally worth it because I ordered the Penne Augustino which is made with extra virgin olive oil & no reg sauce. I ate some the way it came & it was really good but when I added the tomato cream sauce to it I felt it made it really great. My daughter ordered the Penne Amici and loved it especially with extra tomato cream sauce. The prices were reasonable too because both dinners came with a small salad & some really good garlic bread, their own I believe because I've never seen or had before, we both added multiple items to our dishes & extra dressings for the salads. The portions of pasta are in the extra large round tinfoil containers with the domed lids and the salads come with let, grape tom, cuke, Italian black olives & red onion which I think is great for a free salad. Their balsamic, Parmesan peppercorn dressings were very good and their house to me tasted more like golden Italian which isn't my favorite but still ok cause I always mix the Italian with Parm pep or ranch if they don't have my fav creamy Italian which I'd eat like crazy. After getting all that just the way we like it my order total with tax was $50.45 which I feel was a decent price. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to my family and friends. I'm also going to order food from there in the future and maybe even...

I paid $500 for lunch banquet of 16, and it was horrible, absolutely horrible. They also did not refrigerate my $300 wedding cake so it melted and fell apart.

$800 wasted and 5 to 6 hours of my wedding day gone.

My party was scheduled and they had nothing ready for us. They didn't serve us bread and kept us waiting for any type of food for over three hours, that is no exaggeration, it was three hours. I was also never told my party would be split into 3 due to Covid until I arrived, our tables weren't even close to each other. I couldn't see the rest of my family. Had i known that I wouldn't have booked the place. Once seated they gave us disgusting water pitchers with things that were floating in it, and all the glassware was dirty. When I notified them about it they didn't change out the cups, just switched out one and each pitcher (2 more after the first) they brought back had the same floating white stringy stuff. We gave up and didn't drink anything.

Within the first 3-4 hours we weren't served any bread or any appetizers. When we did finally get the food it was absolutely disgusting and bland, the noodles were watery??, chicken soggy from the noodles, & the salad was not a salad, it was cheese and dressing. Everything was still served with no bread, and they refused to make any modifications to any of the plates even though they obviously haven't cooked our food yet, and to top it all off whenever we needed something after the food was ordered it was like pulling teeth, we had to wait for long periods of time after asking multiple times.

Had I not been so exhausted and wanting to cry that day I wouldn't of paid. It ruined my wedding day. And they destroyed my wedding cake by not refrigerating it for the whole 5 hours. Horrible communication. My...

We went here with my family a few weeks ago when they were in town. The hostess was gracious and seated us in a spacious booth. The interior of the restaurant is gorgeous and comfortable. We started with stuffed mushrooms and calamari. Everything was hot and delicious. I especially loved the fried peppers that came with he calamari. As far as entrees go, everyone had HUGE portions that were fresh and flavorful. My husband and Step Dad had chicken parm that was enough to feed two hungry people, easily. My son got the raviolis which were giant! My mom got the chicken marsala which she said was one of the best dishes she's gotten at an Italian restaurant. I got the chicken Christina (Or Christine I can't quite remember the name) everything in the dish was fresh and prepared nicely. My husband, son and I were so impressed that we came back 6 days later for lunch. The portions are smaller but they are still pretty big, especially for the price. That time my son got the Italian Trio which had the best lasagna I've ever tasted! The service was great both times as well. Overall you can not beat the price, service, or freshness at Amici's. This will be a regular place that my family and I will eat at! Can't wait...