Alfie's Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in New York

Best pizza in all of Queens!!!! I've had Sofias on 112st and Rockaway overpriced and had to throw the whole sicilian pie out bc the sauce was so nasty. Tommys on Liberty and 118 st sauce is so sour. By far the best pizza, sicilian and prices!!!! Imagine Tommys sicilian served only 8 slices when a sicilaian is 12 slices and Sofias charged $25 dollars for the same sicilian Alfies charges $18. Ive also had Gabbys Pizza on Hillside which is supposed to be so good, nope service sucked, pizza was soggy and they claim to be the best in queens, not a chance. If your in Richmond Hill you need to try Alfies!!! The secret is always in the sauce. Ive had the famous Park Pizza in Howard Beach , no crust and soggy nothing to rave about. Alfies crust is crunchy and substantial. Marinara is the BEST.....They use fresh veggies if you order pizza with mushrooms your getting fresh mushrooms not the canned mushrooms that most pizzarias use. They also have fresh mozzarella for pizza topping!! OMG they are the best and I never write reviews!! Its so hard these days to find delicous pizza and great prices. Please open more...

One of the standout pizzerias in Queens is this family-owned establishment run by a brother and sister team. Their plain $12 pie is simply amazing and offers great value for money. Personally, I prefer mine with a slight crispiness. It easily holds its own against other local pizza places in Queens like New Park Pizza, House of Dani's, and Nick's Pizzeria.

However, I'm not sure who started the trend that they specialize in square slices because, in reality, their squares are quite mediocre. They tend to be too doughy, which aligns with some other reviews I've read. Additionally, their vegetable pie isn't my favorite due to the use of pickled jalapeños.

However, the place is still stuck in a time capsule for better or worse. While it has its charm, a renovation would be cool to inject some freshness. Adding a touch of individuality and unique style would greatly enhance the overall experience.

On a positive note, I really hope they bring back their pesto pie! It's a delightful option that I highly recommend.

Overall, I would rate their regular pie a solid 7.9/10 and their pesto pie an...

1st of let's start with the 2 guys behind the counter talking about fast food restaurants that they like n wanna go to, as a food critic I think its distasteful to talk about other restaurants you want to go to with patrons in this restaurant, now for the atmosphere very outdated n filled with kids screaming taking up just not the tables but filled the aisle to get to the counter as they watched a movie on TV, so differently not a place for a sit down dinner, now what you all be waiting for is the quality of the food, since we were not able to sit and eat we grab a few square slices as which they are supposedly known for as our squares did not look or taste as One Bite states, they square slices are thick n doughy with extremely sweet n bitter sauce and most of all we got a square slice that was missing a good portion of the cheese.... As I do not recommend this place and my recommendation is based on 2 trips to Alfies, at 2 different times and again it was like romper room with undesirable...