Jimmy's Pizzeria — Restaurant in New York

The only good thing I can say is: Fransisco the food deliverer was pretty good and prompt. I gave Jimmy's Pizzeria a second chance to redeem them selves from the previous order. I previously ordered a Grilled Chicken Gyro with rice and a Meatball Parmigiana hero. The gyro was ok but my order came with spoiled rice and the bread for the hero was very soggy. I called Jimmy's and spoke with "Felipe". Felipe said that he was sorry and that he would keep my number for when I wanted to place another order. I called back to speak with Felipe but was hung up on twice and the person acted as though he couldn't here me speaking into the phone. The gyro today, wasn't as good as the first gyro and the person preparing the food, paid no regards to my notes which was pertaining to the previous order. The hero was soggy again and the hot wings were extremely soggy. There was a ton of breading on the wings. I didn't have to be lied to. That is not good business. I probably won't even get a proper response from this review. $40 wasted! No third time is a...

This is the second time I’ve been there in about a year and this is the absolute last time! I bought a lamb gyro with fries like the last time and the meat was old or fried because it was charred and crispy. There was no crunch or taste to the onions and the souvlaki sauce was of very poor quality and bland. Not even salt and pepper helped this gyro. The French fries were undercooked 🤦‍♀️ Furthermore they don’t wear hairnets or gloves and so they’re touching food with their bare hands. The service is HORRIBLE!! Each time I have been there the guy at the cash register has gotten combative and nasty with other customers. This is a horrible, horrible place to eat no matter how hungry you are which was my case. 👎 👎 I will go and pick food out of trash before I eat...

The gentleman in the front did not give me order gave me just the bag with drinks in it when I got home, I realized that my food wasn’t in that bag I called and was trying to let the gentleman know what happened and he was very rude and nasty and hung up the phone on me when I called back did the same thing ended up having to pay a cab from my house all the way to the back when I get there, he’s yelling at me for his mistake so I politely asked him to give me my money back. I have been doing business with this pizzeria for years so for them to treat a valued customer with such nastiness and rudeness is unacceptable. They need to do better or they’re gonna lose more customers because they lost me will never...