Round Pie Pizza Company — Restaurant in New York

I often underrate this place because they don't deliver and only offer delivery through the delivery apps, which I rarely use.

But I need to stop because the pizza is always good to great.

Today I took advantage of an amazing coupon from their great online rewards program. Every so often they send out coupons if you're signed up on their website. Today's coupon was a free 12" cheese original pie.

I took advantage of the coupon, so I added pepperoni to one side, sausage to the other, garlic purree to the entire thing, and I made it a signature pie (EVOO, Fresh Basil, and parmesan added.) I also requested it well done through the website. This came out to $8 with the coupon.

No joke this was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. It was loaded with toppings and the toppings were reasonably priced. The small pepperoni cups are delicious and the sausage chunks completely covered that side of the pizza. The garlic purree made it taste like a grandma pie and the fresh basil and other signature toppings made an incredible finish.

The pie was cooked perfect. Burnt on the edges but it somehow doesn't taste burnt - it just adds to the experience. The pizza was crispy almost the entire way around despite all the toppings on it. Most delicious pizza I've had in a long time.

Seriously look at my account I've rated a lot of pizza places. This was different and...

Wow!!! Wow!! and again Wow!!! I'm a native Staten Islander that knows all the top pizza places on the Island. I also consider myself a Pizza expert. I tried this place for the first time today and all I can say is Wow!! I'm a huge fan of Deninos and it is pretty much tied with them. I saw a review on Bar Stool Pizza and he gave it like a 7. It definitely is a very solid 10. He lost credibility with me if he didn't think this pizza was easily a 10. I had the Classic pie half pepperoni and half plain and a white pie. Both equally as impressive. I also had the chicken wings and a meat and chicken parm stromboli, and again both outstanding. This is definitely my new go-to place. I'm 56 years old and Pizza is my favorite food and this is pretty much the best Pizza I have ever eaten and that includes New York City and Brooklyn. Staten Island has a new King of Pizza and...

Called J & P's a10:30 on a Saturday night, couldn't order take out. Called D's tavern and pizzeria, they didn't answer the phone though it looked like they were open. Drove around a little more and saw Round Pizza Co. It was just before 11:00 PM. Ordered 2 large cheese pies...they were INCREDIBLE!!! Topping similar to J & P"s, and crust similar to D's tavern.. Open to midnight too. The young lady that took my order was very friendly and beautiful! This is my new FAVORITE pizza venue. Thank you for the GREAT experience. Also recently tried their chicken parmigian with spaghetti and meatballs and spaghetti. Both huge portions, tastes just like J & P's but with 3 meatballs and $8 cheaper. Nice...