Terrible Eddie's — Restaurant in New York

When we heard about Lioni’s heroes being on Staten Island; my co-workers and I were excited to order.

The heroes do not stack up to the original in Brooklyn.

They state they have fresh Lioni’s Mozzarella; they do not. They have this weird sliced squared Mozzarella that was probably fresh over 2 weeks before they sold it. I’ve never seen old, sliced, rubbery, squared mozzarella be called fresh. The taste was disgusting.

We ordered four sandwiches with one common ingredient “Fresh” Lioni’s mozzarella; the outcome for all of us? DIARRHEA.

They should call it Fugazzi’s Mozzarella because it’s definitely not real Lioni’s.

Where is the moist round fresh mozzarella? Why is it this weird refrigerated squared Mozzarella? We ordered 2 hot and 2 cold sandwiches and all got the same cheese.

I was so upset I promised my coworkers I will take my lunch break to go pick up the real deal in Brooklyn.

Please reconsider going here and just drive over the bridge!

If I could give it 0 stars I would.

“Man...

My boyfriend saw this shop on Staten Island Food and wouldn’t stop talking about how good it looked for weeks. I came to visit and we got the #54 on Friday and it was so great that he giggled while eating. Each ingredient would be outstanding on its own but combined…good Lord. We didn’t even talk to each other because we enjoyed eating our sandwich so much! The chicken was well seasoned, the barbecue sauce was unique, and the bread was absolutely perfect! Crispy and flaky on the outside and soft on the inside. We loved it so much that we went back today, two days later, for a #136, and we cannot wait to try all 150! The best part-the sandwich had just enough dressing to be not dry but not so much that it’s soggy. I can’t recommend the service and the food...

My mother had ordered from Brooklyn Italian Heroes for a 30th birthday celebration for me. She ordered a 6 foot American hero, Eggplant wraps, a 4 foot Grilled Chicken hero, Potato Croquettes, Broccoli Rabe, Grilled Vegetables and rice balls. Everything was delicious. The heroes came cut up on platters already which was great. Very convenient and saved so much space The bread on the heroes tasted like it was just baked. It was nice and soft but it had a bite to it. The cold cuts tasted delicious and everything was fresh as could be. This was our first time ordering from Brooklyn Italian Heroes and I'm so glad we did! We will be coming back soon! Everyone at the party enjoyed the...