The Guthrie Inn — Restaurant in New York

The Guthrie may be one of the few bars west of Lex in the area and luckily it's pretty damn good. I stopped in to grab a cocktail after grabbing food and a beer next door. There were a couple seats up front as well as in back so we had no issues there. I had the Donkey Juice which was strong and tasty. My friends had some tiki drink and some smoky drink which they devoured. At $11-$12 a cocktail the drinks are fairly reasonable and they had beers for only $4 and $5. The bartender was friendly and laid back and while we only stayed for one drink we thoroughly enjoyed our self. The combo of The Guthrie Inn and Earls makes for a...

We went there a group of 3 friends on November 26, 2024, the bartender was racist and very unprofessional, we tried to have some drinks we were all over 25 years old, he asked us to show our ID which we did immediately, we were all foreigners an show our national ID, adter he spend like 5 minutes with each ID he told us to leave the place without any explanation maybe he thought we didn't fit in the business or I don't even want to get into why. Very unprofessional, rude and irrational individual the one that was bartending. Will definitely not recommend if your a foreigner maybe for...

This place is great for a private, intimate experience with a few people. There's a small, very secluded single-booth room in the very back that can seat about 8, and the front area has a few small tables. As long as you know it's not a bar to roam around in (it is very small), it's very enjoyable.

The drinks are superb. They're a bit on the pricey side, but similarly priced to other comparable locations in NY that serve high-end drinks. The bartenders know what they're doing and make great drinks. I'd highly recommend their sazerac, New Orlean's...