Benny Rappa the Italian Fisherman — Restaurant in North Myrtle Beach

My family has been a huge fan of Benny’s since he owned Benny Rappa’s years ago, so we were beyond excited to have him back with a brand new restaurant! We got a reservation as soon as possible, and our experience truly exceeded our expectations. It felt like a family reunion walking in and being greeted by Benny and his wife, and that was just the beginning of our wonderful experience. The decor was cozy, with a beach cabin feel that was classy yet fun.

We started off with the red sangria which was very refreshing after a day on the beach, followed by the crab cakes, calamari, and garlic bread as appetizers. All were delicious, but I have to shout out the calamari as it was truly the best I’ve ever had-fresh, not chewy or greasy, lightly battered, with a sweet chili sauce which complemented it perfectly. Next came our salads, and I tried the blue cheese dresssing per a recommendation from a friend who said she loved it despite not liking blue cheese…and I agree, the blue cheese was definitely not overpowering in this dressing and was a great choice.

For entrees, we got the seafood lasagna, the chicken carbonara, the scallops, and the halibut francaise. All were exceptional!! My friend asked what my favorite dish of the 4 was and all I could answer with was “…all of them!” which is just confirmation that you can’t go wrong with any dish on the menu.

For dessert, we shared the limoncello cake which was a great lighter option, and the icing on top of a fantastic dining experience.

I can’t wait to go back to try more as the menu changes weekly (each Monday).

Welcome...

If you’re looking for a delightful dining experience that marries the charm of an Italian eatery with the laid-back vibe of a beach restaurant, Benny Rappa The Italian Fisherman should be on your list! From the moment we arrived—despite the parking lot being full (a good sign!)—the short walk from the next block just built up our anticipation. The atmosphere here is unique. You get the cozy, welcoming feel of an Italian restaurant, but there’s also a breezy, seaside energy that makes it perfect for a relaxing meal. The staff were outstanding, attentive and genuinely friendly, always making sure we had everything we needed. Start your evening with a Blue Marlin martini. The flavor is both refreshing and surprising, making it a standout cocktail that sets the tone for the meal. For dessert, do not miss the Bennycello vodka. It’s a smooth and sweet way to end your meal, almost like a liquid dessert. I ordered the linguine with white clam sauce, and I was blown away! The linguine arrived completely covered with clams in the shell. You could barely see the pasta underneath. Each bite was slightly briny, fresh, and full of flavor. The garlic bread, available for $2.50 at dinner, is warm, crispy, and the perfect companion to soak up every last bit of sauce. Benny Rappa The Italian Fisherman is a gem. Even if you have to park a block away, it’s absolutely worth the walk. With fantastic food, creative drinks, and a one-of-a-kind atmosphere, it’s a restaurant I can’t wait to...

We have been to Benny Rappas many times since they have opened across the street from us. Every dining experience has been terrific! From the welcoming atmosphere of Michele and Benny to the beautiful decor of their restaurant and their attention to detail, including the lighted menus and lighted Checks, . All of their wait staff is just phenomenal, friendly and attentive, and their service is first rate ! The new weekly menu lends to the freshest food that is always perfectly prepared and very delicious! We love this restaurant so much and are so happy that they are part of our Cherry Grove family . Thank you Ben and Michelle and staff for all you do to make your guests feel like family! We'll be back again...